Jeff's On Rugby — Restaurant in Oshkosh

Nice Wisconsin supper club menu, atmosphere, and food. When we sat down we were served warm rolls. The wine & Whiskey selection is minimal. Our server was wonderful and even immediately adjusted the heat when she noticed the draft and that we were cold. My husband had the New York strip special, the steak was done to perfection and tasted delicious! He asked for sauteed onions on top and got two or three onion rings but that was okay. The vegetable medley was a little lackluster as it consisted of a California blend where the broccoli was mostly stalk, but overall his meal was a do-over! I ordered the salmon stuffed with crab and asparagus in a yellow hollandaise-type sauce. Stuffed Salmon Oscar? It was very good if you like crab. My meal came with a salad of very nice greens, perhaps arugula and other dark leafy greens and I believe they have several homemade dressings to offer. We had chocolate cheesecake for dessert. Definitely try it! The desert was excellent! Overall if you like Wisconsin supper clubs, this one has a really good menu, knows how to make a steak, has wonderful kind service, and a decent atmosphere. You won't find fancy wines or tablecloths here, But you'll get a good meal at a fair...

My wife and I decided it was worth sharing this review. Unfortunately, despite a decent atmosphere and good service, the food is simply not worth returning to. I genuinely think that the fact most people drink before they're sat has something to do with all the positive reviews. The bread they serve is delicious, the Old fashions are good, but I've never had food without taste. We seriously thought something was wrong with us. The fried fish literally had no flavor, my Prime rib...which I love generally, had zero taste. Also had more fat on it than I've ever seen anywhere else. The only detectable flavor was black pepper. I had to add salt which I've never done for prime rib. The potato wedges and mashed potatoes were all equally bland. Bummer. We ate what we could and brought home the left overs, next day sure enough...still no flavor yet everything else we ate did. We seriously gave this place a couple shots the last few months, but are back to putting it aside. Wouldn't recommend,...

HORRIBLE!! We threw away more than half of what they delivered bcuz it wasn't edible! The seafood platter at $23.99 had 4 little pieces of fish, each smaller than a mozzerella log, so over fried they were rock hard. The 'mush' inside the 2pcs of stuffed crab was rancid. We got 4pcs of shrimp and a 3inch pc of broiled haddock that was the only thing edible. The Mega Munchies @ $13.99 came with all the cheese blown out of the logs in a stringy hard mess. We got 4 breaded mini corn dogs (not in description) and 3 little chicken tenders. No onion haystacks or cheese curds (that are in the description). The salad leaves were tinged brown and slimey! I was going to call and complain but figured why bother, the fact they let this even go out the door shows they don't care about repeat business. I took pictures but can't seem to attach them. Save your hard earned money and support other restaurants during...