Pennsville Pizza — Restaurant in Pennsville Township

I know the old cliche about nobody makes pizza like north Jersey and New York, but the pepperoni pie that we had tonight from Pennsville Pizza compares to the pizza from north Jersey. Take it from my husband and myself who are native north Jersians, the pizza we had tonight was awesome! We also had their mild buffalo wings, which we asked for them to be crispy. Oh boy, they were great too! Not mushy! This is definitely our new pizzeria! I didn’t give them 5 stars because this was the first time we ordered, so I would need to have several orders be this good for me to give 5 stars.

Update: We have now ordered SEVERAL times. We’ve ordered different pizzas, chicken sandwiches, meatball sandwiches, wings, etc and everything has been exceptional!! Now I can give them 5 stars!! I highly recommend...

I came from Michigan and moved with boyfriend who has had food in past and said its good so we went there and the first time he ordered a tuna wrap the tuna was really nasty tasted spoiled and very runny watery and i had coleslaw and it tasted like its been sitting for days...then we went in the other day again to try something different to see if it would be better and this time was worse..we both ordered pizza burgers and his tasted like there was some kind of chemical on burger and mine tasted like it had lots of garlic..my boyfriend was sick all night with stomach cramps and puking. Complete waste of money and we refuse to go there again...

The only thing good in this place is there pizza..I have tried other food but it's been nasty..the salad was warm and nasty with bugs...the pizza burgers the sauce tasted like it had chemical in it...you can clearly see there food products are not stored properly in a pop fridge with multiple things that should not be together. My boyfriend has got sick from a couple things..we kept trying it hoping things would change but it isn't..I hope they get better or change owners so it can get better before multiple...