Tony's Pizza — Restaurant in San Marino

I’ve been coming to Tony’s Pizza for as long as I can remember. Growing up, nothing beat the student special with a slushie—those are core childhood memories for me. I always thought the same Sicilian family would run Tony’s forever, passing it down through the generations. So when I found out there were new owners, I’ll admit I was nervous.

But to my relief, it’s still Tony’s pizza! The taste, the atmosphere, the comfort—it all brought me back. That being said, I have to mention one small (but big to me) detail: the onions. My go-to has always been sausage and onion, and Tony’s was special because of how they cut them—thin, long, stringy slices that caramelized perfectly in the oven. The new cut is different—chopped longer, thinner pieces—which just doesn’t hit the same. It might sound silly, but for me, that little detail made their pizza stand out from anywhere else.

One friendly suggestion for the new owners: please don’t swap out the original ingredients for other brands. The magic of Tony’s is in the flavor that’s been consistent for decades. Don’t change that!

All in all, I’m so glad Tony’s is still here and still delicious. Change is part of life, but the heart of Tony’s...

Open for take out, dine-in and delivery. Pizza slices or whole pies. Usual hours 11:00 am - 8:00 Tues. - Sat. but check operating hours as they may change. Authentic New York style Italian pizza restaurant originally founded by Tony who was from Italy via New York City. Not trendy nor artisan but excellent pizza since 1973 that you can't get from a chain restaurant. Pasta is good but check on availability of Italian sandwiches. Counter service in restaurant serves carry out and dine in. Prefer credit cards. Paper plates not cloth napkins at this casual restaurant. They have one big TV, often tuned to sports with sound turned down. With San Marino High School next door, menu includes a 'student special' slice combo available for lunch or dinner. No wine or beer but variety of other bottled drinks in addition to Coca-cola fountain drinks and 2 liter bottles. A great place from which to feed the kids. Carry out and delivery are big here. Phone ordering and web ordering is available. Menu is online on their web site. Seating inside at the windows with booth seating right on Huntington drive. Adequate free parking (not valet) in the small parking lot, best to enter from westbound...

First time coming here. We were driving through town looking for Christmas lights and saw this place. They have a great selection of Italian food from salads to sandwiches and ofcourse, pizza. The only bad thing is that if you show up in the evening they run out of ingredients. I ordered a chicken parmesan sandwich and I was told that they were out of chicken. The customer that was in back of me ordered a meatball sandwich and also was told that they were all out of meatballs. I ended up ordering the Meat Lasagna with a side salad and garlic bread. Food was great, I will be coming back here next time I'm in town but will be coming here more earlier. The customer service was awesome. The cashier and the cooks were very hospitable. Definitely recommend this place if your craving Italian and don't want to spend an...