Mi Fortuna Mexican restaurant — Restaurant in Sheboygan

Mi Fortuna Mexican Restaurant: A Hidden Oasis in Sheboygan

In the vast sea of dining options, stumbling upon a truly authentic and memorable restaurant is a rare delight. Mi Fortuna Mexican Restaurant in Sheboygan is one of those hidden places that, thanks to a simple Google search, became an unexpected yet incredible culinary discovery. From the moment we walked in, it was evident that this establishment is a labor of love—where authentic Mexican cuisine meets warm hospitality in a setting that is both quaint and impeccably maintained.

First Impressions: A Cozy and Inviting Atmosphere Tucked away in Sheboygan, Mi Fortuna exudes charm from the moment you step inside. The space is clean, cozy, and inviting, with an atmosphere that immediately puts you at ease. Whether you're looking for a leisurely meal with friends or a quick bite at the small but well-stocked bar in the back, this place offers a welcoming environment that makes you want to stay a little longer.

Service: Attentive, Patient, and Friendly The service at Mi Fortuna was outstanding. The staff was exceptionally patient with all our questions, providing thoughtful recommendations and ensuring we had the best experience possible. Whether you're a seasoned lover of Mexican cuisine or trying something for the first time, don’t hesitate to ask for suggestions—the team here is knowledgeable, kind, and eager to help.

The Food: Authentic, Fresh, and Overflowing with Flavor If there’s one thing that defines Mi Fortuna, it’s the food—fresh, well-seasoned, and undeniably authentic. Every dish that arrived at our table reflected the care and expertise that went into its preparation.

We started with the homemade salsa at the table, a bright and zesty accompaniment to crisp, lightly salted tortilla chips. Wanting to elevate the experience, we also ordered the guacamole, which was velvety smooth with just the right balance of lime, onion, and fresh avocado. It was the kind of guacamole that demands extra chips simply because you won’t want to leave a single bite behind.

For our main course, we indulged in beef chimichangas and al pastor tacos—both of which were exceptional. The chimichangas were golden and crispy on the outside, yet incredibly tender and flavorful on the inside. The al pastor tacos? A revelation. Each bite offered a perfect harmony of spice, smokiness, and sweetness, with the pork beautifully marinated and cooked to perfection.

No meal is complete without a good drink, and Mi Fortuna’s margaritas delivered. Refreshing, well-balanced, and not overly sweet, they complemented the meal without overpowering the flavors of the food. Whether you’re celebrating or simply unwinding after a long day, the margaritas alone are worth a visit.

Final Thoughts: A Must-Visit for Mexican Cuisine Lovers Mi Fortuna is more than just a restaurant—it’s a testament to what great food, exceptional service, and a welcoming atmosphere can create. It far exceeded our expectations, and we’re already looking forward to our next visit. Whether you’re craving bold flavors, comforting classics, or just a great spot to sip on a margarita and enjoy chips and guac at the bar, Mi Fortuna delivers on every level.

A small word of advice: if you’re planning on dining in, dress appropriately. This isn’t a fast-food joint or a casual brat-and-burger hangout. The food and service at Mi Fortuna deserve a little respect—so leave the pajamas and sweats at home, especially if you're over 18. Trust us, this experience is well worth the effort.

For those seeking an authentic Mexican culinary experience in Sheboygan, Mi Fortuna Mexican Restaurant is...

Mi Fortuna Mexican Restaurant – Review

A cozy and colorful spot tucked into South 8th Street in Sheboygan, Mi Fortuna offers a comfortable, modestly-sized dining room with tasteful décor and a casual vibe. Service was timely and efficient, though interaction with the server felt more transactional than warm.

The horchata stood out as excellent—creamy, not overly sweet, and refreshingly spiced. Chips and salsa were standard; the chips were notably thick (a matter of preference), and the salsa options had a surprising jump in heat between mild and hot. Blending them gave a better balance.

The Taco Salad Mi Fortuna was a bit of a mixed bag. It tasted great overall—hearty, well-seasoned—but the steak was on the chewy side and the expected grilled onions and peppers were served raw, which disappointed slightly. The edible shell seemed possibly fried in oil past its prime, lending an off-note.

Parking is easy and free along the street, which is always appreciated.

Final Verdict: 4.5 stars A solid lunch spot with standout horchata and flavor-forward dishes, even if a few texture and prep choices missed the mark. Worth returning with a few adjusted...

We went to Mi Fortuna which is a new Mexican restaurant which opened in February 2025 that is owned by the former owner of the "El Camino" in Sheboygan. Starting with the Salsa, the mild salsa was on the “hot” side. My partner had Taco Salad. The meat was on the bottom of the taco bowl and tasted like it was cooked on old oil. The “salad” portion was a large hunk of iceberg lettuce that was not chopped at all and completely covered the meat.

I had the Burrito al pastor. My meat tasted like it was cooked with or close to some sort of fish. (I happen to not like any fish, and I found the taste disturbing.) The price of the meals was a little on the high side. The service was good and the atmosphere was also “just ok.” We were very disappointed and will not...