HTML SitemapExplore
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Cagney's Pizza King — Restaurant in Shelbyville

Name
Cagney's Pizza King
Description
Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.
Nearby attractions
The Strand Theatre
215 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Grover Center: Museum and Historical Society
52 W Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Shelby County Public Library
57 W Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Knights of Columbus Sacred Heart Council 822
413 E South St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Big Blue River Trailhead
626-698 IN-9, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Nearby restaurants
Chaperral Cafe
14 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Linne's Bakery & Cafe
115 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Greek's Pizzeria Shelbyville
20 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Just Peachy Cafe
52 East Washington St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Grandma's Pancake House
632 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Blue River Bistro and Bar
39 Public Sq, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Cow Palace
318 N Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Blue Agave Mexican Grill & Bar
530 N Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Tierra y Libertad
802 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
KFC
350 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Cagney's Pizza King tourism.Cagney's Pizza King hotels.Cagney's Pizza King bed and breakfast. flights to Cagney's Pizza King.Cagney's Pizza King attractions.Cagney's Pizza King restaurants.Cagney's Pizza King travel.Cagney's Pizza King travel guide.Cagney's Pizza King travel blog.Cagney's Pizza King pictures.Cagney's Pizza King photos.Cagney's Pizza King travel tips.Cagney's Pizza King maps.Cagney's Pizza King things to do.
Cagney's Pizza King things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Cagney's Pizza King
United StatesIndianaShelbyvilleCagney's Pizza King

Basic Info

Cagney's Pizza King

33 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
4.3(582)$$$$
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts.

attractions: The Strand Theatre, Grover Center: Museum and Historical Society, Shelby County Public Library, Knights of Columbus Sacred Heart Council 822, Big Blue River Trailhead, restaurants: Chaperral Cafe, Linne's Bakery & Cafe, Greek's Pizzeria Shelbyville, Just Peachy Cafe, Grandma's Pancake House, Blue River Bistro and Bar, Cow Palace, Blue Agave Mexican Grill & Bar, Tierra y Libertad, KFC
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(317) 392-4677
Website
cagneyspizza.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Shelbyville
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Shelbyville
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Shelbyville
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Burrito Supreme
dish
Chicken Salad Croissant

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Cagney's Pizza King

The Strand Theatre

Grover Center: Museum and Historical Society

Shelby County Public Library

Knights of Columbus Sacred Heart Council 822

Big Blue River Trailhead

The Strand Theatre

The Strand Theatre

4.7

(122)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Grover Center: Museum and Historical Society

Grover Center: Museum and Historical Society

4.8

(62)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Shelby County Public Library

Shelby County Public Library

4.7

(53)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Knights of Columbus Sacred Heart Council 822

Knights of Columbus Sacred Heart Council 822

4.4

(65)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

A Tribute to Bobby Helms Jingle Bell Rock plus all your Christmas favorites!
A Tribute to Bobby Helms Jingle Bell Rock plus all your Christmas favorites!
Sun, Dec 21 • 4:00 PM
122 W. Main St.,Greenfield,IN,46140
View details
Jingle Bell Rockin Tribute Band
Jingle Bell Rockin Tribute Band
Sun, Dec 21 • 4:00 PM
122 West Main Street,Greenfield,IN,46140
View details
Andrew Young Band
Andrew Young Band
Fri, Dec 26 • 10:00 PM
8810 S. Emerson Ave,Greenwood,IN,46237
View details

Nearby restaurants of Cagney's Pizza King

Chaperral Cafe

Linne's Bakery & Cafe

Greek's Pizzeria Shelbyville

Just Peachy Cafe

Grandma's Pancake House

Blue River Bistro and Bar

Cow Palace

Blue Agave Mexican Grill & Bar

Tierra y Libertad

KFC

Chaperral Cafe

Chaperral Cafe

4.5

(352)

$

Click for details
Linne's Bakery & Cafe

Linne's Bakery & Cafe

4.6

(193)

Click for details
Greek's Pizzeria Shelbyville

Greek's Pizzeria Shelbyville

4.2

(141)

Click for details
Just Peachy Cafe

Just Peachy Cafe

4.8

(157)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Reviews of Cagney's Pizza King

4.3
(582)
avatar
1.0
8y

Great food but the most unprofessional staff I have ever seen. Cagneys used to be amazing but the waitresses are horrible. The last three times I've been in there, waitresses have been arguing and gossiping about everything. Who has a table, who stole a table, what they will do to the waitress who stole a table, how horrible that person is...all the while cursing up a storm RIGHT IN FRONT OF CUSTOMERS! How can anyone allow this to happen? Where is management? The worst is the red head with the tattos. She was supposed to be our waitress but she was too busy running to the bar over and over. Finally, the sweetest waitress, Jennifer, came over and apologized no one had helped us. She said she wasn't our waitress but she would get our drinks. Thank goodness! Our supposed waitress kept going to the bar. Jennifer came over again and took our order. She repeated she wasn't our waitress but she would get our order. At that point I told her I WANTED her to be our waitress. Sure enough Miss Redhead shows up and starts talking loudly with another person about how our table was stolen from her. This involve 10 minutes of swearing and griping and insulting poor Jennifer all in front of customers and my 5 year old. Go ahead...ask me how happy I am about this woman swearing in front of my child. By the time Jennifer brought our bill she was in tears. I took out a 10 and handed it to her. I told her I didn't trust that the red head would not steal the tip from her bc it was her table. Jennifer did the work so Jennifer got the tip. What's truly funny is that the red head who swears, insults, gossips and yells is the only one who has been there for at least the last 4 years. Seriously cagneys? No wonder there were only about 5 tables filled on a Saturday night. Jennifer deserves better. The others deserve reprimand and in my opinion, firing bc I've seen it every time...and heard it too. It's funny! The owner has replied to everyone on here about how he will fix the behavior of his employees...yet he doesn't. If I wanted reality TV, I would have ordered Papa Johns and eaten at home. It would have been a much more pleasant experience. I'm over the drama at...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
8y

We were in on Friday night August 18. We waited 10 minutes in the bar area and never got waited on. So we thought we would try the dinning room. As we were walking to the dinning room the bar maid yells out, I was going to make it to the back you guys. We just kept walking. It was obvious she was too busy and couldn't handle the patrons in the bar herself. She desperately needed some help. We were the only ones in the dinning room at first. We ordered our food and the waitress never brought my salad. She was an older woman with a flower carved out of her hair on the side of her head. So I finally got her attention and asked for my salad. She brought it and that was the last time we seen her. She stayed at the other end of the dinning room. Another waitress was filling her other tables drinks. But no one came back to fill my husbands. He tried to get the attention of the other waitress but she would just turn her head and act like she never seen him. She was an older lady with her hair pulled back in a ponytail. So I gave him what was left of my drink so he could finish eating. We waited on the recite but no one brought it to us so we walked to the counter to check out. There were six people standing there talking, the phones ringing off the hook behind them and they all act like couldn't hear them. So if you go in there stay away from the grown women that has a flower carved out of her hair on the side of her head. She is the worst waitress I have ever had in my life. We as business owners ourselves, started laughing when we left because we couldn't believe what we had experienced. Hardly no one in the dining room but overflowed with workers standing around using dirty vocabulary. The bar was packed and only one person trying to handle all the customers. I will say this about the owner. We have met him and had conversations with him and I can assure you if he was there this bad service would not...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
1y

Every time when I come 2 Indiana Scott.... they fell to get my order right enough is enough so.... Then when I call 2 tell them they want to make me out of liar like really.... I know what I wanted to eat not what they just wanted to deliver me its getting OLD....saying I order something I never did... The REAL TRUTH is cause they FAIL to put my order i place RIGHT BIG FACTS !! Don't blame me 4 your mess up this has happened to many times and enough is enough I'll place my orders 4 now on to people who can take call in orders RIGHT Cause I assure you people they will mess up your order when you call in place a order then blame you 4 their actions.. what gets me when you repeat yourself what you wanted to order and they still cannot place your order right.... we know what we want to eat when placing a order.NOT what they want 2 give US then blame us 4 their mistake. ..wrong so wrong and DON'T even offer us anything after its all paid 4!!! What happened the customer is always right especially when they know what they want to eat that night... Then the tacos was so greasy comes pouring out Bad business and bad service enough is...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Chris BlackburnChris Blackburn
The food was decent. The person handling the phones not so much. I was told 15-20 minutes is when my food would be ready. I got there 25 minutes after I ordered. My food wasn't ready and when I asked why i was told 20 minutes instead of the actual time it would be, the woman was very snarky and explained that at least it would be cold, and they are slammed so... I would get someone else on the phone instead of this older woman who clearly has no patience for a customers question. All I got was 2 burritos.
Love LifeLove Life
Just called in to order a pizza 10/22 at 4pm. The lady on the phone was very unpleasant. She was ill tempered and short on the phone. Not sure I’ll enjoy the pizza as I haven’t eaten it yet. But won’t go back based on phone experience. Where I come from a little kindness goes a long way. Update: cold pizza. Pizza should have pepperoni slices and sausage chunks not frozen “meat” bits.
James MurphyJames Murphy
Well, Cagney's is okay to eat there but getting more expensive, best to order the daily specials. Been eating here for 40+ years and I believe its time for a change. The kitchen and dining area need a complete overhaul. The staff, well they could present themselves better in my humble opinion. The BBQ pizza still rocks.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Shelbyville

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

The food was decent. The person handling the phones not so much. I was told 15-20 minutes is when my food would be ready. I got there 25 minutes after I ordered. My food wasn't ready and when I asked why i was told 20 minutes instead of the actual time it would be, the woman was very snarky and explained that at least it would be cold, and they are slammed so... I would get someone else on the phone instead of this older woman who clearly has no patience for a customers question. All I got was 2 burritos.
Chris Blackburn

Chris Blackburn

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Shelbyville

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Just called in to order a pizza 10/22 at 4pm. The lady on the phone was very unpleasant. She was ill tempered and short on the phone. Not sure I’ll enjoy the pizza as I haven’t eaten it yet. But won’t go back based on phone experience. Where I come from a little kindness goes a long way. Update: cold pizza. Pizza should have pepperoni slices and sausage chunks not frozen “meat” bits.
Love Life

Love Life

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Shelbyville

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Well, Cagney's is okay to eat there but getting more expensive, best to order the daily specials. Been eating here for 40+ years and I believe its time for a change. The kitchen and dining area need a complete overhaul. The staff, well they could present themselves better in my humble opinion. The BBQ pizza still rocks.
James Murphy

James Murphy

See more posts
See more posts