Caffe Italia — Restaurant in Shelton

This is a cute little place with about 6 tables for dining in. We first went here for a Sunday morning brunch after Mass. I had a tomato frittata & American coffee. My husband had the Bacon Frittata Sandwich. Both frittatas were delicious but when I heard the tantalizing crunch as my husband bit into his rustic bread, I instantly regretted not ordering the sandwich. Still, even the no-bread frittata was delicious. I’ve had a lot of frittatas and bad ones are often overcooked. Caffe Italia cooks theirs perfectly: lovely velvety eggs with sliced tomatoes, a sprinkle of Parmigiana, salt & pepper, and fresh mozzarella. My husband’s bacon was crispy and not greasy. Caffe Italia is on River Road in Shelton. We haven’t had lunch or dinner there yet but we intend to. (The sandwiches & dinner plates I saw looked wonderful!) If you drive that road, I’d highly recommend stopping in. And if you don’t drive River Road, you won’t regret going out of your way.

They do Italian right: high quality, simple ingredients cooked perfectly.

They also have refrigerated precooked classic Italian dinners like Chicken or Eggplant Parm, Manicotti, Lasagna, soups like Pasta Fagiole & Escarole Bean as well as Italian pantry fare such as imported olive oil, pasta and sauce — and much more.

Service was excellent: friendly yet professional. Priced very...

Would like to start by saying this os 2 stars- regarding LAST VISIT only (I hope). Ive been here on multiple occasions, and the young lady working, was polite and provided great service. This time i was served by, based on educated deduction, must be the owner.

I walked in and seemed to be bothering the man working, as he sucked his lips before telling his buddies “I gotta handle this.” Ordered a BACON and egg sandwich. Gentleman confirmed “no cheese?” And I responded “no cheese.” I also ordered a Proscuitto Panini (an Italian PRESSED sandwich) with no cheese. My breakfast sandwich had NO BACON but it did have CHEESE. I have an intestinal issue and cheese causes my stomach to bleed. So guess that was a loss. And my other sandwich wasnt pressed at all.

For the amount I spent, i could have went an extra 10 ft, and given my money to Subway. I would have 2 much larger sandwiches, made the way they were...

Embarking on a culinary journey at Caffè Italia in Shelton is truly an enchanting experience for all who adore Italian flavors. The warmth of the cafe is not only reflected in its cozy, inviting ambiance but also brilliantly mirrored by the friendly, attentive staff who seem genuinely devoted to elevating your dining experience. The Prosciutto Panini is an undeniable star on the menu, with its thinly-sliced, savory prosciutto enveloped between freshly baked bread, creating a symphony of flavors and textures that is both hearty and sublime. The Cappuccinos are equally praiseworthy - smooth, robust, and crowned with the perfect froth, offering a delicate balance that coffee lovers will undoubtedly appreciate. Whether for a leisurely brunch or an afternoon pick-me-up, Caffè Italia stands out as a gem in Shelton, promising a blissful retreat with...