Tasty Creme of Library — Restaurant in South Park Township

This place has a very old-fashioned-looking setup. The pictures of their menu items look really old - like in-need-of-replacement type old. The first few times we drove past it, we honestly thought the whole building looked abandoned.

I was kind of overwhelmed by how many options they had so I panicked and went with the vanilla soft serve cone.

They deserve credit for filling up the cone 100% - literally to the absolute bottom of the cone. How do you even do that?

Let me tell you - the cream is tasty but not that creamy. Now, this is coming from someone who’s really only used to Rita’s and McDonald’s soft serve which in texture may be smooth as smooth can be, but I think the taste can be attributed to very very small bits of what might be… white chocolate shavings in the ice cream? It was hard to tell but I...

After reading all of the reviews, I was very excited to try to this and I’m always a fan of supporting local. The staff was very friendly and helpful. I was hoping for a soft serve place that offered some options other than chocolate and vanilla and this wasn’t the place. I was told they had swirls to add to it so I got a banana swirl and it had no flavor. My wife got a peanutbutter flurry that had no peanutbutter taste. My daughter got a strawberry shortcake and felt the vanilla has no flavor.

Just a subpar local institution that didn’t give us any reason...

Better than DQ and way more options. I don't know what happened with Patty Grose's experience for her nasty review, but they DO have a place to sit that is shaded by an umbrella and trees. For service, no one has ever been rude to me or my family and the hours aren't much different from other treats shops. My experience has only been top notch. I hope she trys them again. They are family owned and have been serving the locals of South Park and Bethel Park for a very, very long time. You don't stay open that long giving everyone the experience Patty...