Gary's Pizza — Restaurant in St. Joseph

Hosted a Birthday Celebration for 30 guests at Bad Habbit in St Joseph on Saturday. Ordered pizza and a salad for guests to arrive at 5:45pm from Gary’s Pizza. The Wednesday prior, paid for the pizza and salad, generous tip and delivery. Confirmed Friday, Saturday no pizza, called restaurant 6:00pm they didn’t have my order, told me 35-60 minute wait!!! We walked 1/2 block to get our pizza after 1 hour wait. Waited 15 additional min. in line. No salad! Then called the next morning to talk to a manager because the phones were not reachable on Saturday! The restaurant manager offered me $50 in store credit on a $200 order, 1 hour wait, had to pick up my own order no salad, and to top it off I have to drive and get the $50 credit! I will never recommend this place ever. Very disappointing for my 30 guests. I would recommend using someone else if hosting a...

The owner/employees probably know who I am as Im the "no cheese, veggie pizza guy." Ive always had a good experience here, really professional/friendly staff. Half the time I order, they seem to really load up on the toppings because I always request no cheese, so I always appreciate that. As far as the quality, it is good pizza. They say their crust is vegan, hopefully it actually is since I know that Sliced told me their crust has dairy in it. The hours are good. I can order a pizza damn near any time I want it and it usually doesnt take very long. Keep up the...

We’ve ordered from this place three times now and they do NOT disappoint! Plenty of cheese and toppings. We got a large sausage and pepperoni the first time, and when we noticed that there was and entire pepperoni LAYER over the whole thing, we were hooked. Fast, accurate, piping hot and delicious. My ONLY complaint is that the delivery drivers don’t have crushed red pepper and Parmesan on hand. You have to ask when ordering, but that’s really minor. A+. Oh, and you can have them deliver to Bad Habit Brewery right down the street if you want craft beer...