Pie Guy Pizza — Restaurant in St. Louis

❤️❤️❤️Love this pizza! New to my family. Tried it during day but had originally put this spot on my late night new to try spot list! Saw a list of open late night spots in St. Louis, Missouri as I get so tired of chain restaurants being the only ones open late. I am a foodie and want FLAVOR late night too! This pizza box is PINK! Located in The Grove (gay district) so pretty central to city and not terribly far for county dwellers. Or order it to be delivered! The pizza is 18”. Cost for 2 toppings is $30 with tax. Cost for a GIANT pizza slice cost is around $4-$5. Worth every cent! Slices are huge! Crust is on the thinner side (and I usually hate thin crust). It is the right chewiness for thin crust pizza. Toppings were fresh. Like the mushrooms are fresh NOT from a can. (*See Keith Lee’s recent pizza review in NEW YORK!) I will immediately black list a pizza joint if they put canned mushrooms on our pizza. Every topping was nice. Even the sun dried tomatoes-on my daughter’s half but I had to nick a piece of the tomato! The pepperonis were unlike any I have ever gotten on a pepperoni pizza. Then I saw Keith Lee in NY getting the very same thing on his pizza. So good! We ordered for pick up but the temp in the spot was just right. Not too hot or too cold. There is side for pick ups and a side to eat in. Nice atmosphere from what we saw. We usually are nite owls but happened to be out when all hell broke loose on the highways and regular streets at 2:30pm for getting out of DODGE for the Christmas holiday! 🥳Like Arnold says,...

Had a crave for a New York style pizza, and after browsing through multiple options, I decided go here for the first time. Ordered a large sausage, bacon, and pepperoni pizza. $41 dollars in total after adding dipping sauces. The pizza was way too salty, and I’m known to over season food at times according to others, but it still taste good to me, so when I say it was salty and unsatisfactory it was just that. The presentation of the pizza was great looked really good. Plus all the great reviews, I didn’t expect anything less than satisfaction. As I mentioned before I had all the dipping sauces which included the marinara sauce and when I tasted that on its own it wasn’t salty at all, so I wonder if it was just a simple mistake made by the cook…? I’ve never written a review on any establishment before and my reason I’m doing so is because the pizza looked so good and everybody else’s food who were dining in there and outside looked great! So for it too be so salty I can’t even eat it, was huge let down. Great and friendly staff, my only disappointment was how salty the pizza was.

Update: Went back and the owner was great, honored his word and replaced the pizza. Now that I can taste everything in the pizza I can easily say one of the best pizzas...

5 stars on all counts.

I ordered a pizza online last friday, scheduled to be sent to me last sunday. I've done it with pie guys before, and the order went through like it's done in the past.

Well, it turned out sunday was easter, and they closed that day. I got a call from a delivery person that sunday letting me know they couldn't make the delivery. I could expect a refund and a discount and so on.

So today, I was looking at my credit card statement and noticed there still was no discount applied, and no emails from pie guys explaining/apologizing. So I called and reminded them, "Hey, listen, yadda yadda I never got my pizza and I never got my refund." Immediately set up the refund for me and offered a free pizza on my next order, instead of just some kind of discount. I told them "Look, if you just make a pizza for me right now, we can call it square." And, they did. I walked right down to the place and got it fresh out the oven. Now I'm sitting here letting it cool so I don't burn my mouth trying to eat it like I always do.

They owned up to their mistake, gave me more back than I was expecting, nothing but polite about it, and the pizza is still good. 5 stars...