Anthony's Restaurant-Pizzeria — Restaurant in Stafford Township

I've been on LBI for a while and was dying for some Wings and a Cheesesteak, I'm very picky about both, the cost on the Island for wings is outrageous, and the cheesesteaks hardly have meat and are expensive too. So I google Wings and found this place and took a chance. Everyone working was super friendly, ordered my wings and cheesesteak with fried onions, and there it was ready within 15 minutes. The wings were very good, the hot sauce was tasty. The Cheesesteak was amazing. There was tons of meat, and it was extremely tasty. The roll was so fresh. I only ate half and saved the other half for the next day, and ended up eating it cold . It was still extremely good, and the roll head up overnight....

AUTHENTIC. That’s the best word I can use to describe this place. Synonyms for that also work. Legit. Real. Honest. True. Found this place on the Google, so glad. That’s the Meat Lovers pizza. Oh, and the large is only $1 more than the medium. Seriously? If you don’t order the large, WHAT ARE YOU EVEN DOING? This became our dinner for TWO nights because we (me and my wife) could only eat HALF on our first sitting. Bacon, ham, sausage, pepperoni…perfect crust…cheese was terrific too. Cooked exactly the way you would expect. Awesome decor. Wonderful staff. This place has been around forever, I think, at least 25 years. That’s one sure way to know it’s … authentic. The real deal. JUST GO EAT HERE...

I ordered their minestrone soup to discover it was actually a can of Progresso that they warmed up and put in a to-go container, it was unmistakable. The audacity of that! Otherwise, the pizza is good, the wings are rubbery, the garlic knots are excellent, skip the antipasta salad (oily iceberg lettuce with mostly unmemorable toppings, though the olives in it are decent enough). But what a disappointing scam with the soup! If I wanted a can of Progresso I'd spend a buck or two at the grocery store, definitely wouldn't intentionally pay...