Pizza Supreme — Restaurant in Town of Broadalbin

This place was recommended to me, and I can't tell you the level of shear disappointment. It was a Saturday evening around 5:30. I walked in to get a couple of slices. They didn't have much to offer, just 3 dried up old plain slices and nothing else. So I order a small cheese pie and a chicken parm hero. I was told 45 minutes. Waited in my truck for 40 minutes went back in, the lady took my money with the hero in hand, but told me it would be another 15 minutes for the pie. Finally pizza came out and I headed home. When I arrived the pizza was the worst I've ever had. To much sauce, and over cooked. The chicken parm hero you ask? Bread was soggy and when I opened it, there were chicken fingers covered in too much sauce again. I'll never go back, and the people that recommended it to me will get an ear full. I give it a 2.2 out of 10. In a...

Huge shoutout to Pizza Supreme for honoring their hours unlike so many other businesses I’ve been to over the years. Called at 7:50 to order when they are advertised to close at 8 (Didn’t want to be that guy but got out of work early and really wanted their pizza lol). Told me it wasn’t too late and pickup would be around 8:15 which is obviously 15 minutes past advertised closing. I know to some this probably sounds like it should be automatic but I have experienced so many businesses that turn things off over 30-45 minutes before close, say they are no longer taking orders, etc. I’ve always been under the mindset that as a business you should be making food until your advertised closed time. If you want to be out at 8, then advertise until 7:30 so people know. Thanks again Pizza Supreme! Food was...

It's alright/good food. IMO it's not the best pizza in the area, but it isn't bad. The sauce is too sweet for my taste.

The main issue I have is two-fold: It's pickup only so no delivery, and cash only. I recognize that these two things might not be possible for their current business model, but when their competitors in the area (with better pizza IMO) do have delivery and credit-card, it makes it tough to recommend or order from here.

Additionally, the lines to pick up are usually quite long, sometimes 10-15min of waiting in line. Its frustrating to stand there knowing your order is waiting. This is another area where allowing credit-cards would be hugely beneficial. Again, I do understand the business reason...