The Pizza Cutters 2 — Restaurant in Town of De Witt

I rarely leave reviews, truly. Even when disappointed I don’t take the time of day to review, I just don’t order again. However, a week ish ago I ordered a vodka riggie pizza and let me tell you. It was hands down the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. I have thought about that pizza everyday since the last time I ordered it. I decided today to order the pizza again and I was disappointed before I even tasted it. It didn’t even look like the same pizza. The taste? Was horrible. It was literally dough, cheese, and giant chunks of fried chicken. I called and asked what the difference could be from and I was told “it all depends what we scoop onto the ladle while making the pizza”. Which okay, maybe I understand if there’s a significant amount of cherry peppers, but I’m telling you there wasn’t even sauce on this thing. I took a bite and even pulled a slice apart. It was strictly cheese, dough. Not a sliver of cherry pepper in sight.

In the restaurants defense, they said I could have a credit but from the attitude of the owner when I called, I didn’t even care for a credit because if it’s going to be so dependent on “the scoop of the ladle” I will simply try around until I find a more reliable and...

Ordered a large pie, and 20 medium wings, extra crispy. Was quoted 30 minutes. We waited 15 minutes then drove over. Went inside at the 30 minute mark. I gave her my name and a few minutes later she rang me out ($53.00), and said, it’ll be ready in 8 minutes. We sat outside for 10 minutes, and walked back inside. We stood at the counter for another 5 (place was a ghost town, nobody there other than 3 workers). Not so much as a “just a couple minutes”. She handed us the wings and said, there ya go… I asked, “is there pizza?” She replied, it’s not ready yet. A few minutes passed and our pizza was out of the oven. When I tell you there was 4” of empty box next to our pie in the box it’s no exaggeration. This pizza measured just a hair over 12” across. The wings were done extra crispy, but had NO sauce on them (discovered this after driving home). The pizza sauce had large chunks of basil stems throughout it, and was not good. Would give zero stars if possible. How this place had 4.4* reviews...

I've ordered from this place a couple of times now and they are fantastic! I wish I had pictures but I don't. I can tell you that my friend and I were very impressed with the food. I will warn that they use Doordash for deliveries after 9pm and Doordash is the absolute worst. You're better off picking up late-night, however the owner (or manager maybe? I'm not sure) actually drove my order to my house himself because Doordash wasn't sending a driver and he didn't want the food to get cold! Despite being late, which was NOT the restaurant's fault at all, it was delivered with a smile and the food was still very hot and fresh! On top of that, he threw in a free piece of cheesecake and two dessert eggrolls which were all fantastic! It's been a while since I've witnessed such incredible customer service and I will absolutely be back. It was a great deal and worth the wait. I highly recommend the luna style pizzas and anything with their boom boom...