The Seafood Shop — Restaurant in Town of East Hampton

Spectacular Seafood…Exceptional Staff…Tremendous Value!!! The Seafood Shop is a MUST for those who live in the Hamptons (although you probably know this already) and especially those like us who visit the Hamptons periodically and want to get the highest quality meal for a tremendous value served up by a super accommodating staff! There honestly isn’t the need to go out to fancy restaurants because The Seafood Shop prepares out of this world made to order meals that are both plentiful but most importantly SUPER DELICIOUS! We had grilled Halibut with two sides the past two days that was cooked to perfection! Our compliments to the chef as it was honestly THE BEST Halibut we have EVER had…light and white and flaky delectable! Onion rings, waffle cut fries(extra crispy) and fried veggies as the sides garnished with lettuce leaf, huge tomato slice and a wedge of lemon…we couldn’t finish it all as the halibut portion and sides were so plentiful! And what’s incredible is that for two meals it costs only $47 including tax! We challenge anyone to find this kind of quality and value anywhere! Thanks to owner Colin and our new friend, Andrew, who made sure our orders were perfect we will continue to plan our meals around The Seafood Shop each and every day we are in the Hamptons. Once you try it we’re sure you will agree....

I have been driving past this place for years on my way to and from Montauk. I finally made a stop this past weekend to get some little neck clams for Memorial day weekend. While we were there we decided to grab a lobster roll and a fried flounder sandwich for lunch. The gentleman helping me was very friendly and recommended we get 5 dozen clams based on the amount of people we had. The lobster roll was delicious and fairly priced. It comes with a side of, rice, fries, or onion rings. The fried flounder was also very good. Most things are fairly priced but the lobster salad was priced at $70 per pound. I don't know what they're smoking charging that much. You can pick up 2 pound and a quarter lobster for about $10 a pound, have them steamed for you at the supermarket, add some mayo and celery and have your own lobster salad for about 1/4 of the price. Yes this is prepared for you but $70 is ridiculous. I could understand $20 a pound, Hamptons or not. No need to...

This is is the very best roadside seafood stop I’ve ever visited in the US. A fishmonger’s dream of selections, including local porgy and huge striped bass. Absolutely fresh seafood, with an extensive selection of prepared savory dishes and tart garnish, available by the pound. Highly recommend the Portuguese octopus salad, shrimp salad, pico de gallo and mango salad. For the hot menu, they have just about everything one could want from a delectable smorgasbord of fresh seafood harvest. I suggest the Super Combo, to get an introduction to the menu. It includes fried fresh local flounder, shrimp, scallops and clams - FRESH, hand breaded clams. For those looking for fresh oysters and clams, you won’t be disappointed. Combined with local Montauk iced tea, and you’ve got an excellent meal. Finally, they have colossal live lobsters at very decent prices. I believe the day I visited, it was 4 lobsters for 60...