Garden City Pizza and Catering — Restaurant in Town of Hempstead

Very good, friendly service, but their pepperoni slice is mediocre.

Bread-like edge crust, with a floppy base crust. Edge crust crumbled and broke when I tried to fold the slice. Base crust nearly ripped off the edge crust when lifting it with one hand off the plate. Cheese and sauce slid off the slice when taking bites or trying to lift it off the plate.

Edge crust should be chewy. A slice should be solid even when hot. Foldable, edible with one hand, the entire slice should not droop down into the plate.

Otherwise it tastes good, and they were generous with the pepperoni. Still would likely order a pie from here instead of a...

From the days of the Italian Kitchen back in the 70s until now under the direction of Greg, folks can enjoy eating pizza of all kinds as well as great salads and entrees. Always a favorite dining spot, Greg generously supports a number of community endeavors and brings an array of delectable's such as garlic knot sandwiches, shrimp caesar salad slices, and more. Their pizza is always good, and my favorite is their lasagna pizza. It has lots of meat, cheese, and sauce. So next time you have a party, ask Greg to cater to it as your guests will...

I don’t live very far from this place and I have been ordering here for a few years now. I tell everyone about it. They have the best pizza, pasta, buffalo wings etc. This place is the best pizzeria I’ve ever been to. Won’t order anywhere else. I always get it delivered because it’s mobbed inside all the time. The staff are very nice, pleasant and always get my order right and not to mention they give you a lot for your money. I hope this place stays in business forever! Keep up the...