Carl's Main Street Deli — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

Carl’s Main Street Deli is a total gem. As someone always on the run, this place delivers every time — fast, clean, and packed with options. Whether I’m grabbing my pickle, a side, and a large iced coffee (a must!), or stopping in for a quick sandwich, it’s always top-notch service.

Located right off 25A with easy parking, it’s the perfect neighborhood deli. They’ve got variety for everyone, and the vibe is always welcoming — sports on the TV (usually golf, sometimes not the Islanders 😄), great music, and an awesome team behind the counter.

I’ve realized that hockey fans make great business owners — they’re grounded, community-driven people. This is the kind of spot where they want to know you by name, because they’re just normal people serving the neighborhood with pride.

The salad station is excellent, but don’t sleep on the cutlets — everything they make is solid. If you're in the area, definitely put Carl’s on your radar.

Appreciate everything you do for the community — thank you, Carl’s! –...

I've lived in Huntington all my life and only started going here recently. I've always thought the best Delis we're in Northport and Huntington really only had above average Delis. But this place surprised me. Sofia's Place has always been my go to, but I've added this spot into the mix now as well cause it's just that damn good. Great breakfast! Now I gotta try them for lunch!

EDIT: Okay went here for lunch. The BLT was hands down best I've ever had. I need to remember that this place exists because it's so off the beaten path I forget...

Place seems lacking compared to other high end deli’s in the area. They should shop around and see how they can fill their cases with more creative salads, etc. The original case salads tasted pretty basic, bland and could definitely be better. Ordered a bacon egg and cheese once and there was no bacon on it. The bagel also tasted like it was one of those frozen bagels you buy in the frozen section of the supermarket at Trader Joe’s. For a $10 sandwich, the least they could do is buy local...