La Nonna's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

Stopped in a little after 11am—perfect timing as all the fresh pies were just coming out of the oven. They had your classics like Margherita and Sicilian, but what really caught our attention was the variety of specialty pies, each one loaded and sauced up.

We had to split a few slices to sample as many as we could. The tomato white slice, traditional slice, and the vodka meatball slice were all excellent, but that meatball slice stole the show—fresh mozzarella and creamy vodka sauce made it absolutely perfect.

Just as we were getting full, the meat Stromboli came out piping hot and too tempting to pass up, so we grabbed one to go. We also added a chicken club slice with bacon and thousand island dressing—something I’d never seen before, and it didn’t disappoint.

While we waited, we enjoyed watching the staff joke around and interact with each other and customers. It reminded me of the classic neighborhood pizzerias I grew up with—great energy, great food, and great people.

They’ve got solid lunch specials too. Between the fresh, delicious food and the welcoming vibe, this spot is going to be a regular lunch stop whenever I’m...

Ordered a family deal two large pizza 12 garlic knots and a 2 litter for 42$ I was told over the phone had about 69$ in my account once I got there to tap pay for the food price was 47$ which was okay I figured taxes no big deal so I tap pay and the payment comes back declined canceled he says it’s on my bank end an I have to wait for the money tomorrow it happens all the time just pay again and I will receive the money tomorrow I only had 69$ in my account to feed my family till pay day tomorrow long story short I got no pizza the man guessing the owner had no remorse left with no food and no money to buy more food just the hope of wait till tomorrow for my money to go back into my account this is ridiculous and very unfair if your machine does this all the time maybe have a sign or have a better paying system where peoples money is not on hold till the next day because your system declined the transaction which had sufficient funds to process now my kids get no pizza and can’t even go out and order some where else because my money is now on...

Price on their website says $15.95 for a large pie, then they charge me $23 when I point out the price on the website is wrong and that they should honor it I’m told they can’t do it (meanwhile they have a special that’s two pies for $30 making them $15 each less than the $15.95 which means they obviously can do it) and it’s probably the price from when the Mets won the World Series in 86 he says, well change it, it’s a website and it’s dishonest to post one price and charge another. I will be reporting them to consumer protections through attorney generals office for price gouging and for falsely advertising the price and they will hopefully be fined and forced to update it. Do the right thing by your customers it’s not hard. When I arrive I hear them talking about it making negative comments about the person that called not knowing it was me. People these days I mean they’re the ones falsely advertising the price and I’m the asshole? Stay away from...