Isabella's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Islip

Excellent pizza slices which are overpriced. Two neapolitan buffalo chicken slices for eight dollars. That is thirty two dollars for a whole pie. Lobster tails are less expensive. If they were to offer (they have no intention to do so) a sicilian (thick crust) slice for the pricepoint it would be reasonable and essier to eat due to the weight and moisture of the toppings.

I am still waiting for them to come to their senses. Most of the other pizza venues nationwide offer the rectangular version of this item. This review is much longer than you or I care to read.

One more item: The iceberg lettuce and red-colored, not vine-ripened, salad with oil and vinegar was horrible. I threw it on the trash. Salad must have something green in it...not albino leaves.

I like the management very much, but they could be better with the products they sell. If I ran the place there there would be a line out the door to the bar next door. Now I am done. Maybe. Yeah,...

Terrible experience for 2nd time. Moved to Westbrook Village & Isabellas became our go to pizza place. Unfortunately pandemic followed and the rules and guidelines set by state are not being followed at Isabellas. Picked up pizza tonight and a group of teenagers hanging out were there without masks. They were not eating and were not at tables. Help was young too and may have been friends. I suggested to kids that they should have masks on. They were obnoxious and said they had me on before. Very disrespectful and acted like they owned the place. No signs at all about no mask no service. The help heard the commotion and ignored everything. The establishment should be reported to the state. Las time I picked up pie an older gentleman was there without a mask stating his political views on masks. Not one time did the establishment post or request that customers wear masks. Done with that...

Both food price quality and quantity is very good it's one of those places that's hold that standard for quite a while the fires are great it's the first place I want a pizza place they actually made a Greek salad and they put the grape leaves in it and it beat most prices by $3 or better boss works it and takes pride in his food the delivery is bouncing in and out of there like crazy it look like the orders are very timely though I have not have it delivered. I live too far away but I definitely go out of my way to get the food it's well worth a drive it sets the standard worth the trip and the seafood calamari pie is off the hook he used to have it on Fridays but prices got to be expensive to make it but if you made it you definitely get what you pay for I miss those Friday nights when he made it it comes back in the summer I'll be knocking on...