Salsa Salsa Bayport — Restaurant in Town of Islip

Horrible service! Lucy, the child taking orders is obnoxious. I have been ordering from this restaurant every week for months. I order the same exact thing every week and she never remembers me or even has a polite acknowledgement. Which is somewhat forgivable even though I think someone who is a regular customer should be treated better than that. However the thing that's unforgivable is how rude she just was to me on the phone basically mocking me the way I was ordering my meal. When I asked to speak to a manager she lied to me and said she was the only person in the store. I don't appreciate being lied to… I don't appreciate being ridiculed… I don't appreciate the restaurant not appreciating my business. So I will take my business to avocados or any of the other Mexican restaurants that do just as well making burritos. Hey maybe they'll even appreciate...

Just had the worst experience I’ve been coming here forever. The food was burnt. The pulled pork on the nachos was hard as a rock. I live 30 minutes away and the manager wanted me to drive back to return it and then said to me oh how do I not know you just want you on nachos never in my life had I have a manager running establishment and speak to a customer that way completely disgusting really hope that you change your manager and understand that that’s not how you deal with the customer When I explained to her that both of them were hard as a rock she said when I packaged it and spoke to the Cook and he said it wasn’t burnt so arguing with a customer in itself is a problem completely disgusted...

On busy nights when we want something quick, healthy, and satisfying, the CrossFit menu is a standout—chicken and shrimp always cooked to perfection, and the salsa and guacamole are always fresh and flavorful. The food is consistently excellent, and the service is just as reliable. Oscar, the owner, is exceptional—always attentive, efficient, kind, and genuinely committed to creating a great experience for every customer. We’re grateful to have a place like this in the...