Quaker Hill Tavern — Restaurant in Town of New Castle

Quaker Hill Tavern is an absolute gem! From the moment you step inside, the warm and welcoming atmosphere invites you to relax and enjoy. The service here is top-notch with staff who make you feel like family, always attentive and ready to make your experience memorable.

But let's talk about the food... it's simply out of this world! Every dish is a hit, but the Chicken Wings? They're the best I've ever had. Perfectly cooked, with a mouthwatering flavor that leaves you craving more. Quaker Hill Tavern has nailed the perfect balance of crispy skin and tender meat with a sauce that is a delicious blend of spices.

Whether you're here for a casual lunch or a cozy dinner, you'll leave satisfied and longing for your next visit. Quaker Hill Tavern ticks all the boxes for a 5-star dining experience. Can't...

Never again. Where to even begin. The service was terrible. The girl who worked there had no manors at all. Didn’t know how to greet people. Waited for menus. Took her 10 minutes to come and ask for our drinks. 15-20 minutes to ask for our food. There were like 2 tables of people dining. The food felt like it took 40 minutes to come out. Never came to give us refills or anything. Then we ask for check, she brings it and when we gave her the money and asked for change she brought it back to us didn’t even say thank you, take care. Bye nothing just dropped it on table and walked away. Just rude. If you want to wait 3 business days for your food, just come here. I won’t be coming back here anymore. That wasn’t a...

This place has gone downhill! Service was good after what was a less than friendly welcoming from staff/tender. Tender redeemed herself and was super sweet to our daughter. Food was the WORST I have had of pub food in the longest time. We set out for a great night of just that, pub food and a beer with kids. Could not have been more disappointed. Calamari was disgusting and made us sick. Reuben was not even toasted. Tuna tacos were just ok for a signature item. Facility is also dreary and run down now. Only good of the night was a freshly poured Guinness that most pub/taverns should not get wrong. For a mainstay of “Chappaqua” they need to get their act together...