Uncle Tommy's Tavern — Restaurant in Town of Orangetown

So I’m shocked to read anything positive about the food here. We opted to choose a local spot today instead of the vendors at the street fair (our mistake). Don’t get me wrong… our bartender Eileen… super nice and hospitable. That’s where it ended. The cheesesteak was like they took a fatty cheap steak, cut it up super thick and threw it in a pan until grey, slapped it on a bun with what looked like McDonald’s grade processed cheese. We had to spit out 1/3 of the meat due to the inability to chew it. NOTHING like a cheesesteak. Two people sharing it and we didn’t finish it. The fries tasted like they haven’t changed the oil since god knows when. We also ordered a French onion soup. I’m not sure WHAT we were served but it wasn’t French onion soup. Looked good but the broth was like sorta oniony flavored water and we didn’t eat it. My hard cider was the best part. Unfortunately my 2nd drink ( kettle one on the rocks with a splash of club and lemons), was so oddly bitter and funky. Honestly, if it weren’t for the nice lady serving us, I should have sent it ALL back. I left feeling sick. Sorry to the owner to write this but I have a lot of experience in the restaurant business and I feel you should know. Maybe this was a bad day but my god was it bad. I had to go sample something at the street fair to get rid of the bad after taste in my mouth. The souvlaki at the fair smelled and looked so delicious, I regretted our choice. Lastly, if I were serving food and saw what we left behind, I would have asked if...

⸻

I had a wonderful experience at Uncle Tommy’s Tavern! The food was absolutely amazing — full of flavor, perfectly cooked, and beautifully presented. Every dish we tried was delicious. The service was also outstanding: the staff was friendly, attentive, and professional throughout the entire evening. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for great food and top-notch service. Can’t wait...

Fantastic place for food, beer, music, sports and a great place for friends together. I was in NYC for a few weeks for work and Dermot and the gang looked after me when I dropped in. There is a large Irish community in Pearl River so I was welcomed immediately. I definitely recommend you drop in if you're in the area, you won't be...