Carlo’s Pizza of Glen Head — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

Upon first glance this place doesn’t look like much. But TRUST ME THEY HAVE THE BEST ROLLS EVER. I have traveled hours at times to come to this place. Not for their pizza no, but their BUFFALO CHICKEN ROLLS. I’m sure a normal person would order 3 maybe 5 rolls but you must order the whole tray. If you don’t you will regret waking up the next morning and and having to make the drive all over again. And that’s if there are any left. You have to visit this hidden gem and try...

I don't understand all of these negative reviews but I can tell you that these are all wrong. I have been going to their East Meadow store for years even though I live in Glen Cove because of their amazing food and I'm so happy they opened a new store in Glen Head because it's much closer to my house. Their pizza is incredible and the dinners/catering never fail to please my family and I. Best Italian in the North Shore!! Try the Chicken Parm and...

my food at Carlos is always A+. their vodka slice/pie is my favorite and always a hit at any party I bring it to. can’t forget to mention, their staff is always so kind and accommodating. Jonathan, Kent and Elvis always have a friendly smile, remember your order and go above and beyond for...