The Treatery Long Island — Restaurant in Town of Riverhead

Great grilled cheese sandwiches cookies are exceptional. Going back to taste the gelato. I’ve now been back because their grill cheese sandwich is delicious and made on great bread. Worth five stars. For families coming in to buy just cookies be aware that prices start at $3 each and upwards. This can get expensive when coming in with two children and they want two cookies each. The gelato is $6. For a small cup. In general the going rate on the North Fork. Surprise for-all who may have traveled to Sicily where brioche and gelato was born. Here it is $12. More than Double the patisserie price I paid on the eolian islands. And there the brioche and gelato tasted better. The decor and the ability to eat in the outdoor area is very nice.

I wish they baked smaller loaves of bread. They are huge. Price $14. I would have bought one but I am a single person and the size is really over the top. Half that size and they would sell faster. There were several loaves and the walk-in trade just passed them by.

June 2023. I went in to buy a gift card for a friend with several great grandchildren. Surprise to see her write on a business card the amount and put it in a small cookie bag. When I asked if they had a more familiar looking gift card I was told not yet. Really. A business card! Wont do that again until they have something more secure than a business card. I give them NO STARS for business smarts.

July 2023. I give 5stars for the grilled cheese. I like the traditional. Very nice melt. I go back for this delightful tasting version. The bread on display still huge. Do try the chocolate cchip...

By far, my favorite bakery for treats out eat! My addiction is those delectable cookies, particularly the triple chocolate chip, and the peanut butter (chocolate) chip. I was never a big peanut butter cookie fan until I encountered the ones from the Treatery. Literally a game changer and life changer…… the best peanut butter chip cookie you will have! I’ve developed an immense addiction to the triple chocolate chip as well. They have delicious cupcakes and a host of other goodies and treats that you must treat yourself to ( has appropriately named) when venturing out to the Hamptons, the North Fork, etc., anywhere out east! As it’s winter and I’m currently in Manhattan, I ordered some via mail order. They arrived in the best packaging assortment. The tastiest decision I could possibly make! Just as delicious and fresh as if I went into the bake shop and got them personally. Even if you can’t get out there to pick them up firsthand, I recommend ordering a dozen or two or more to cure any sweet tooth craving you have. I love these cookies so much and I am so happy I can get these in the winter months that I’m stuck...

I couldn’t be happier with the cake for my wedding—it was absolutely perfect in every way. From the very beginning, Dawn and Christina, listened so carefully to what I envisioned and brought it to life exactly as I had hoped. The design was stunning, beautifully detailed, and matched the style of our wedding perfectly.

Not only did the cake look incredible, but it also tasted amazing! Guests kept coming up to us throughout the night to say how delicious it was, and many mentioned it was one of the best wedding cakes they’d ever had.

Working with Treatery Long Island was such a wonderful experience—Christina was professional, kind, and truly passionate about her craft. I felt confident throughout the entire process that she cared just as much about the end result as I did, and she delivered flawlessly.

If you’re looking for someone who will create a cake that’s both beautiful and delicious, I can’t recommend the Treatery Long Island enough. She made such a special part of our day unforgettable. We are...