The 1901 Grill — Restaurant in Town of Shelter Island

Sept '24 - Food was good while we were eating. Nothing special and expensive for what it was. However, 2 of the 4 of us got very sick after lunch here (and had not had anything else to eat) - one of us had all the symptoms of food poisoning, and this person had the bluefish sandwich. The other sick person had the beet salad and said, upon reflection, the cheese was very pungent. The two who did not get sick had the burger & BLT.

Our assumption is, being the end of the season, the fish & cheese had expired or not been properly stored and they were just trying to get rid of what was in stock.

If you like golf, the course is nice to look at but the water is barely visible off...

First time here since this location changed hands and became 1901. Service is outstanding, well coordinated and friendly. Not always something you experience this early in the season at other island venues. 1901 offers casual, good food. I ordered the fish and chips - fish was solid, french fries could be upgraded to a more tasty fry. Portion size for this entree is small, thus four stars. Another family member had the pulled pork sandwich and that was very good and filling. Overall, a solid choice for you to try - casual and tasty fare with a...

Wow !!! What an experience at the 1901!!!! Saw the Buffalo wings going to another table - looked and smelled great. We ordered them and they surpassed the what we saw and smelled. Katherine the bartender suggested the smash burger - chef Casey nailed it !!!! Oh - and the pints of miller lite were cold and fresh. Did I mention the views to the south of the south fork and to the north of Dering Harbor. A MUST stop on...