shortstop pizza — Restaurant in Town of Smithtown

Just got pizza today and was very very disappointed! I have bought pizza lots of times and it was good but today we ordered a pie to have at my mother in laws and it was as if it was a recooked pie. It was dry and hard and almost inedible. It definitely was not a fresh made pie. So there's nothing we can do now but a tip for them . Make sure you make a fresh pie, no one likes a dried up cardboard tasting pizza. Very...

People working the counter never get the order right. If I ask for bbq slices, they'll start putting in bacon ranch ones. After I tell them they put in the wrong ones, they'll throw the right ones in without taking out the wrong ones. After that, they try and change for all the slices. Finally, if I order to stay, the worker still tries boxing up the...

This place has been a staple for me for the last 8 years. I’ve consistently bought and loved the buffalo chicken slice for so long. Over the last year or so, the Buffalo slices have become a gewy mess. It’s difficult to even pick up the slice without everything on it sliding off. Would love if they could go back to making it the way...