I would love to give them 5 stars because their pizza is awesome, but I’ve had a couple bad experiences in the past year to bring my overall rating down to 4 stars. First pre-covid I went there for my birthday, and everything was great honestly, except they gave me a side salad with obviously brown lettuce in it. Second/ third post Covid we tried to order pizza for pick up, and whomever answered the phone both times around 8:15pm told us the kitchen was closed at 8pm, the first time was in the beginning of Covid, so I wasn’t upset, everything had gotten confusing, but this time tonight 8/15/20 I had checked their website which had a post Covid update to list their dining room hours till 9pm, and the bottom of the page listing their hours in general as being open till 11pm on Saturdays. So I assumed they were at least open till 9, and maybe takeout was till 11, or worst case scenario you would think maybe they would close the kitchen at 8:30pm before full close of dining room at 9pm. So due to false advertising on their OWN website, I ended up ordering from another place that IS open. Also, even google and yelp say they are open, which is why I’m writing this to let you all know to place your order by like 7:30ish if you want Nick’s, and because I don’t think it’s very kind/is definitely lazy of the owner to not correctly list hours on their own website at the very least, I had my heart set on Nicks and am disappointed, if it were me, I’d also update it on google and yelp also, which I’ve submitted the hours update for them on google.