Jay's Original Hoagies — Restaurant in Tulsa

I can't say enough good things about Jay's! I've recommended this no-flare, hole-in-the-wall, hoagie shop to just about everyone I know and don't know. With fresh hoagie bread, meat sliced on-the-spot and delicious ingredients, this hoagie shop knocks majority of sandwich places out of the park. Also, Jay and his staff are really helpful offering suggestions when stuck. I typically order an 8" hoagie and it disappears within moments and I'm not left feeling bloated. I've tried half a dozen different sandwiches and would honestly recommend any of them, and as others noted, the sweet peppers are seriously delicious! Side note - every other Saturday Dr. Clyde is in the house offering humor and magic tricks to all that enter. So if you're looking for some time to kill and food to eat with the fam - this will surely be the place for you. Jay's Original Hoagies is a great business and if you're a sandwich junkie like myself - I wouldn't dare skip out. Even when I move, I will come back and support - thanks...

This place is a ABSOLUTE MUST. If you are ever in Tulsa and want an incredible sandwich from an old fashion deli.....look no further.

I was immediately greeted by an awesome lady named Aly. She talked me through the different options and asked what meats I liked. Then she says "I'll just make you a great sandwich." Obviously I defer to the professional and she didn't disappoint. She made me the Italian Special which comes with ham, salami, genoa and capicola. Best part of my sandwich were the homemade hot peppers. Absolutely amazing if your a fan of spice.

While making my sandwich the owner Jay came out and chatted with me and told a story on where the hoagie comes from. This was great to see. You don't meet many business owners who have Jays passion and enthusiasm while treating customers with incredible service.

This is a great family owned business with a special spin on sandwiches. I will definitely be back every time I come to Tulsa. Keep up the great work...

Jay’s Original Hoagies isn’t just a sandwich shop—it’s Tulsa’s happy place in hoagie form. The bread is soft inside with a perfect crust, the meats and cheeses are stacked like a masterpiece, and every bite tastes fresh and full of care.

Jay, the owner, pours his heart into every sandwich, and Rob, his right-hand man, delivers them with precision and pride. They never forget a face—walk in once and you’re greeted like an old friend.

The atmosphere is bright, warm, and full of life. On any given day, you’ll see families enjoying lunch, police officers grabbing a bite, and runners refueling after a workout. Everyone fits in here, and nobody leaves hungry.

If you’re in Tulsa and skip Jay’s, you’re missing out on more than just a sandwich—you’re missing out on a community wrapped in fresh bread.

Final verdict: Jay makes the sandwiches, Rob makes them perfect, and together they’ll ruin you for any other deli in town—in the best...