Crusty's Pizza — Restaurant in Warwick

I think they are the best pizza in this area however my only issue is that they cut their pizza into 12 slices and I literally hate eating a small piece like that because Iike to fold my piece of pizza so when we call we ask for 8 slices and they never accommodate this. today my husband called them and I told him to make sure they cut it into 8 slices so when he gets their the older gentleman who works there (who is very nice) told my husband that he cut it into 12 because they like people to get the variety of a lot of pieces of pizza... wth seriously?!?! so you are telling me that even though I asked you to cut my pizza into 8 pieces because I have obviously been here and know that you do 12 and I don't like it you decided that you would go ahead and do what you like best on MY pizza!!! honestly who does this. I was so upset I told my husband to just get me chipotle because I was to upset to eat their pizza because of this. PLEASE WHEN I ASK FOR MY PIZZA TO BE CUT INTO 8 SLICES, JUST DO IT. I don't care if you like yours cut into 12 I like mine cut into 8. I realize this is such a silly thing to complain about and honestly if they just messed up and forgot and cut it into 12 like they have in the past I wouldn't be so upset it is just the fact that they know I said 8 and decided to do what they think is best for me. I won't be coming here for a while now I am gonna try to see if I can find somewhere else in warwick close to me I haven tried yet and if I don't find anything as good or better I might give this place...

First time going here on recommendation of a buddy at work. Looked it up and saw great reviews so I tried it out that same day.

Let me tell you, Crusty’s Pizza has incredible pizza! We ordered a pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms pizza and a steak and cheese. It tasted fresh and amazing, I was stoked to see that they roll their own dough! That plus the fresh ingredients makes a hugeeee difference. The pizza was so enjoyable right down to the crust! The steak and cheese was also really delicious. The meat actually seems like it was seasoned rather than just cooked steak. And boy they stuff that steak in there! It’s actually a little bit of a detriment, in that there’s too much steak and not enough cheese! But most likely remedied by adding extra cheese. I just put some more cheese and mayo on it at home. I know this is long but I’ll end with this. When I was waiting for the food, I saw on the wall many many MANY photos of a little league baseball team throughout the years that Crusty’s Pizza has sponsored. Now being a little leaguer myself, I felt this was the cherry on top. Love it so far, can’t wait to go back and try their spinach pies. Only reason I have the atmosphere 3 stars is just because it’s a small place. But...

Unbeknownst to me as a newcomer this haunt is a Warwick institution with a extremely loyal following mostly comprised of mature patrons that have been frequenting the establishment for years. The service staff engages you with jovial, friendly manners that speaks volumes for their understanding of how to operate a service based business. Unfortunately, the pizza was extremely ordinary fresh and does not hold up to at home reheating. The dine-in is below average atmosphere in dire need of remodeling but if your a fan of mid 70s booth decor you will be in...