Pizzeria Piccola — Restaurant in Wauwatosa

Mangia mangia (eat, eat)! Pizzeria Piccola Bartolotta does it again. They seem to 'get it right' at their restaurants. Somehow, the pizza here is closely replicated authentically from Italy or Europe (for real). As it should be. The tasteful, but meaningful crust is quite thin, crisp and has a very pleasing consistent dough. More satisfying though, is that it isn't oily like so many other pizzeria's like to bake it. And, it's NOT heavy like a gut buster! Ugh... The salad's equally authentically tasty with a lighter balsamic dressing. Even better yet, the prices are quite reasonable. They also have different pasta dishes. When the weather's cooperative in WI., which can be a rarity, there's an adjacent courtyard to enjoy your food (a bit of being in Italy feel) that they'll bring out to you. You must order inside first, though. We'll be going back. Saturday fall evenings, even earlier (05:30 pm) after football games they're busy so bring your a bit of your...

Pizzeria Piccola makes a great pizza that is as good as most I've had. Their pizzas are personal-sized so make sure you order accordingly. The crust was thin - just the way I like it. They had no problem making a couple pies without cheese for us. Crust is important in a pizza and, of course, the flavor of the toppings. But, what I find distinguishes a great pizza from a good one is the depth of flavoring provided by the sauce and/or seasoning. Pizzeria Piccola's flavors were very good but weren't quite the best I've had, hence the 4-star rating instead of 5-stars. It was really close to being extraordinary. Making a very good pizza is still a good thing. Also, they have a great outdoor seating area. We didn't get to enjoy it but it is a...

Was in Milwaukee from out of town and ordered 4 pizzas to be delivered. Pizzas were delivered by Uber Eats and 3 of the 4 were damaged. 2 of the pizza toppings had slid off of the pizza crust and were sitting at one side of the box. The other pizza just had cheese on it but the slices were all sitting at one side of the box and cheese was everywhere but where it was supposed to be. Called the restaurant looking for a replacement of the pizzas or a refund but was told by the manager that I had to call Uber Eats and take the issue up with them. Uber Eats gave us a $5 credit towards our next order. Extremely disappointed with the service of the restaurant as well...