Amy's Cake Pop Shop/Alibi Cookies — Restaurant in Webster Groves

We had such a delightful experience at Amy's Cake Pop Shop! Our Elf on the Shelf had a "pick-up" for the cutest teeny tiny cake pops, and we couldn’t resist stopping by about an hour before closing. The lady working was absolutely phenomenal—so kind and helpful, which really stood out.

She took the time to tell us about the local makers featured in the shop, and there was so much adorable stuff to choose from—T-shirts, ornaments, 3D-printed figures, and even lots of whiskey-themed items! It’s the perfect spot for unique stocking stuffers and gifts.

On top of that, the cocoa bombs and cake pops were so good! Everything was delicious and beautifully made.

We can’t wait to come back and shop again. Thank you for such a wonderful visit! We can't wait...

Fantastic shop! We attended a class there last night and Amy couldn’t have been a more engaged and professional teacher. She shared her tips and behind the scenes tricks for how she makes her cake pops and had the whole room engaged for the entire class! Her products are consistently interesting and delicious and she is a wonderful member of the Webster business community. We love visiting her store and seeing the creative cake pops and interesting other merchandise (I got my brother a great special whiskey bottle there as a birthday gift last year and he loved it!) and a cake pop class with her was just even more fun! Her daughter also assisted and was very engaged and helpful the entire time....

I have ordered cake pops for my son’s class on a couple of occasions. They were always really cute. But rather pricy so I never tried one. The other day my sister and I stopped by the store to try some flavors and what a disappointment they proved to be. The cake is mushy and almost fudge like. It has no flavor even though we brought various flavors of pops. The cake was so mushy and fudge like and strange tasting that my sister thought the cake was uncooked. It’s nice that they make gluten free pops and the decorations for the pops are super cute but they taste terrible. I’ve had better cake pops at Starbucks. I would avoid this place. The pops are cute but...