Minico's Italian Restaurant — Restaurant in Westerville

4/1/25 I get lots of DoorDashes from here and decided to stop in to give them a try. The food is absolutely amazing! I had the breaded mushrooms and a pepperoni pizza. Absolutely the best pizza I’ve found anywhere in central Ohio! Affordable as well! The mushrooms were fantastic, except a couple of the larger ones were cold in the center. Not a huge fan of square cut pizza either but it doesn’t matter. I’ll definitely be back for the food. The staff is always super nice and I love their unique decor. You have to stop in!

4/10/25 Came back in for dinner, had fried green beans and the Veal Parm dine in special. Had their new waitress, Mandy. Super sweet and very charismatic. She’s doing a fantastic job! The best wait staff I’ve had in a long time anywhere. The food was absolutely perfect! Definitely my new go to. This visit definitely made up for the slightly frozen fried mushrooms I had my first visit and earned them 5 stars all across from me.

4/11/25 Came back for lunch this time, the gentleman who waited on me was quite friendly, and the food was delicious. I had their Super sub and an order of their chicken wings. The quality of meats on the sub were above any of their competition and the sub roll was the perfect texture. The wings were perfectly seasoned and crispy. Love this place! All these carbs might not be the best for me but at this point I’m dedicated to working through the menu lol Only suggestion I’d make is for them to rethink the desserts, maybe do a terimisu or dessert pizza? Keep up the...

A long term resident of Westerville, I have been going to Minico’s for both dine-in and take-out for many years, even when they were on Sunbury Road in Central College. We were running behind on yard work and it was getting late so I ordered take-out; subs for me and my daughter, one with banana peppers and one without. It took several calls to place the order and at least a half dozen calls just rang busy. Ready to go elsewhere I gave it one more call and they answered, I placed my order, and they did not ask my name.

When I showed up they asked my name and I said that you did not request my name but told them what my order was. The young man at the counter was very rude and said ‘well, you didn’t talk to me’. I really felt awkward not knowing what to say and I repeated my order and he just said that’s $17.00. I paid the money and stood there waiting and the lady behind the counter wrapped the 2 subs, put them in a bag and literally tossed them across the counter at me. I asked her/them why they are throwing food at me and they said they are really busy and asked me to take my order and leave.

I have never been this humiliated as a paying customer before. I don’t know if they are the same or different owners but cannot understand how they can treat people this way. When I got home I looked at the sub ‘with banana peppers’ and found only 3. I will never go back to this place even if I am...

I don’t often go to places without pizza in the name to get pizza, but Minico’s may have changed that. I ordered the Italian sub and a cheese pizza with roasted peppers. The first thing I noticed was the golden crisp of both of the doughs, with the gentlest crack with every mouthwatering bite. Once I got through the breading, the flavor of the ingredients whisked me away to the farms they came from. I could taste the fresh tomatoes with every bite of the pizza and each spice in the meat of the sub. The staff was very nice and someone came out of the kitchen to help me when he noticed the person at the register was occupied. The inside of the restaurant also had a very cozy atmosphere. One thing that I must comment on is that I originally wanted a cheese pizza but they are priced as cheese with one topping. I dont know if they add extra cheese to make up for the price of one topping but this is the first place I have seen that starts pricing with one topping instead of just cheese. I will be highly recommending this restaurant to people on their hunt for...