Spice Kitchen Indian Cuisine — Restaurant in Winter Garden

2020: First time ordering. Nice to have an indian option and the food was ok. Butter chicken was actually too buttery and you could see the oily residue of the butter on top which threw off the texture. Rather than being rich and creamy tasting it was overly runny and buttery. Also ordered chicken vindaloo. Not being an expert on vindaloo it's hard to do a comparison to a good one so all I can do is rate it based on flavor. It was adequately spiced and tasted fine. It's on the tangy side but I think that's how vindaloo is from what I've heard. Portion sizes were borderline fair for the price. Overall not a bad experience and I'll try some other dishes in the future.

2021 feb update: I went out on a limb and ordered from here again despite my previous experience. So happy I did. Not sure if they changed chefs but the food was outstanding. Butter chicken was creamy, perfect sweetness and full of flavor. Only downside was the thin chicken strip in there. Portion size was good but chunks of chicken would be much better. The lamb curry was absolutely solid. Beautiful rich brown color, great flavor and the hot was perfect didn't kill me. Changing my rating from the 3 star early last year to a five star now! Host Pooja was delightful to deal with. Highly recommend as long as they keep this consistency.

2021 sep. Another great experience today. Butter chicken was amazing and so was chicken korma. Both perfectly spiced, consistency perfectly and heat level great. Really enjoying the food from...

Carted for a family event at home. They kindly a kicommodate request for food trials and we chose several items including goat curry, vegetable bhiriany, aloo & cauliflower and butter tofu...onion bhagias and samosa. And a few desserts. We were expecting around 120 guests. Somewhere, I also remembered white basmati rice.

They delivered on time and we were able to setup buffet style before guest arrived...kept warm with the small alcohol burners.

Everyone tucked in heartily, having several helpings. There was a lot of food left over, even after everyone had eaten.

Many people got containers and took food home.

We are still eating the food after 2 weeks.

In summary - the food was delicious... everyone enjoyed the meal.

The quantities were generous.

Good food always makes for a wonderful event.

Thank Spice...

Spice Kitchen is a true hole-in-the-wall gem that delivers authentic, bold flavors and an experience you won’t forget. It’s a small spot—just two tables inside an Indian supermarket—but that adds to its charm. Eating there felt like stepping into a traditional, no-frills, home-style Indian eatery, and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming.

Huge shoutout to Chef Pritam, who was incredibly attentive and made sure everything was perfect. His passion for cooking shines through in every bite! We had the Paneer and Chicken Tikka Masala, and both were absolutely phenomenal—rich, flavorful, and perfectly spiced.

Whether you’re grabbing takeout or snagging one of the two tables to enjoy your meal in the market, this place is a must-visit for anyone craving amazing Indian food....