YORK54 Pizza — Restaurant in York

Pulled in here while out for a drive. Reviews were good so decided to try it out. Was smaller than expected with limited seating so had high hopes for really good food. Our waitress was super friendly and she kept checking to make sure we had everything we needed throughout the meal. Onto our appetizer the garlic bread was the worst Ive ever tasted. There was a thick paste of raw garlic that overpowered everything. Tasted like biting into a garlic clove and left both our stomaches upset for hours. Home made lemonade had no sugar at all so basically paid $2+ for a glass of lemon water (which is free at most places). My Fiance ordered a chicken quesadilla which she described as strange and overpowered by caramelized onions which just didn't work. My pizza was just “ok” but being so thin you tasted the toppings more than the pizza itself. Young guy on his laptop that appeared to be a manager or owner continued loud personal conversations with another employee during our stay but didn't get his hands dirty. He spoke to the waitress with a lack of basic respect while getting off his chair just long enough to shout “is that fridge all cleaned” then quickly sitting back down. He never once interacted with customers and appeared irrelevant. With all the great local restaurants we would not recommend or...

My wife and I recently visited York Harbor, ME for New Years weekend. We stopped at York 54 for lunch when we first arrived. It's located right off Interstate 95 on Route 1 at the York exit. From the outside it's not much to look at, but it's what's inside that really matters. They offer mostly a variety of sandwiches and pizzas using fresh ingredients. We both ordered sandwiches. The bread is actually pizza dough. It's folded in half with the ingredients of the sandwich inside. Both sandwiches were amazing! When we left we told them we'd be back but I didn't think it would be the next day. We met with another couple later that day that we were spending the weekend with. The next day we spent exploring the area and when it was lunch time the couple asked if we could go back to York 54 after we told them how much we enjoyed it. York Harbor and nearby Ogunquit offer many good places to eat but we said sure. We started off with the Butternut Squash Gratin bread bowl which was unbelievable! We all ordered different pizzas for lunch and no one was disappointed. If you're in the area and want a quick, delicious lunch., look no further...

My family and I loved this place, the food was really good. We had the cheese bread and brussel sprouts for starters, my 7 year old even liked the brussel sprouts. For our meal we had 3 personal pizzas Blanca, garlic and green veggie, and hard cider bbq. Each of pizzas we had a great balance of flavors with the bbq being my favorite. The only warning I would give is that the garlic are whole cloves roasted, I liked it this way but I know some people don't like garlic that much.

I have seen on other reviews(Yelp) that the hostess was short on the phone and estimated the time wrong. I will say that was not my experience at all I watched as she waited on tables, cleaned tables, took orders on the phone, and dealt with pickup orders the entire time I was there. I was there for about 1hr and the influx of people never stopped between phone calls and pickups she never even had chance to take a short break and she was still attentive to us.

I would definitely visit this place again on my next...