Calabria Pizza — Attraction in Hamilton

PLEASE SUPPORT THIS PLACE and Keep them Going Strong. New York Pizza is a rarity around Cincy, especially anywhere near here. Flying Pizza in Mason and Westshore Pizza in West Chester near Kings Island were good BUT both of them have been gone for years now. My wife and I were pleased to see this place by our home and were hopeful.... and well, WOW! The New York Pizza is the BEST I've ever had...and I mean ANYWHERE. The sauce,cheese and Crust were perfection. That Undercarriage is pure Artwork. Tasted just as great the next day as well. My wife had the Sausage Roll...which is like a Meatball Sub that you dip in sauce.....and it was the best Meatballs I've ever tasted. Soooo flavorful. Had a Conoli as well that was great...a bit pricey but will get again for a special dessert here and there. Fast Service on a Saturday afternoon. 15 mins. The man and woman there were very welcoming and everything was very clean as well. I NEVER leave reviews...not really my thing, but this place needs our support. Keep up the great work!...and welcome...

We had large pizza, garlic rolls, and the tiramisu. The pizza was NY style half pepperoni. The pepperoni was mild but tasty. The pizza had good undercarriage not too greasy and the crust was a good bite all on its own. No pizza handles were discarded in the box. Good to the last bite. The garlic rolls on the other hand were not as great. Was like a rolled out over baked stale biscuit that was doused in butter and garlic. Hard on the outside and kinda stale in the middle. Finally, the tiramisu. Very small for price, and the taste was mainstream store bought. That being said it was sweet and not terrible but if you really like tiramisu it clocks in below the bar. However, if you haven’t really had tiramisu before it’s a good entry level version of what the dessert should be. Over all I give the pizza a 6.8 out of 10. Shout out Dave Portinoy, the garlic rolls a 1.8 out of 10., and the tiramisu a 5.6 out of 10. Price is a bit high for quality and portion size...

Called in for a pick up @ 6:30pm. They say arrive at 7:15. 45mins fair enough. We get there with the awful parking situation outside of the building & have to wait an additional 15mins for our food.

Salad - 1/10 - lettuce & ranch

Garlic knots - 3/10 - just knots with Parmesan, maybe forgot the garlic.

Meat lovers stromboli - 6/10 - edible, nothing fantastic

Baked ziti - 5/10 - pasta was mushy Did not get bread sticks that was supposed to come with the Ziti. -1 point.

Canoli - 5/10 - just a average tasting sweet.

Carrot cake - 6/10 - was not given with the order, had to go back and get it. -2 points.

Overall, this place is 4 minutes from the house and I probably won't go back. I'll drive the extra 5 mins and go get Pizza Chef down...