Denig Jewelers — Attraction in Sharon Township

My boyfriend and I were on a hunt for the perfect diamond to set in an engagement ring. We looked all over Columbus and had 3 highly reviewed jewelers looking for loose stones for us. We just couldn't find the right diamond. We walked into Denig, saying to ourselves that if they couldn't find anything there, we would have to go to Cincinnati to look around. At first, we were a little nervous when they mentioned that their diamond supplier was a company from NY that sold diamonds online(NY Diamond Traders). We decided to go ahead and have Pam ask and see if they had anything we would be interested in. She called a few days later to inform us that she had a diamond coming and couldn't wait for us to see the stone. Still apprehensive about the whole online supplier process, we went back to see the diamond, which was in a setting at the time. It was THE ONE! I could hardly believe that Denig and the NY company had gotten it right on the first try! I was beginning to think that I would have to lower my expectations to find a diamond that was "just OK", but they found what we had been searching for. Then came the best part. Denig said that they would be happy to remove the stone from the setting before we purchased it, so I could take a closer look. They also showed me how to look at the diamond under magnification and match the inclusions with what was on the GIA certification. They were so patient and helpful! Not to mention, the price was UNBEATABLE compared to other jewelers. They were also able to send my boyfriend's payment information to NY Diamond Traders while we waited in the store for a few minutes. They sent the confirmation back to Denig and we took the diamond home with us that same visit! I was very pleased with the level of service and the overall friendliness and patience of the staff at Denig. I would also hope that this review might help others feel more comfortable buying from an online trader, especially one who lets you see and examine the loose stone in person before making the purchase! Everyone was professional and we will surely go back to Denig...

We have nothing but the highest recommendation for Denig Jewelers in Worthington! We first visited Denig last year when looking for someone in the area to fix my grandmother's engagement ring; this was after Kay botched the fix for the third time. (Denig fixed this same ring about 8 months later at no cost, even though it was my fault the prong broke again - It is too old to wear regularly, oops!) In July of last year, my fiance visited Denig on his own in search of my engagement ring! Cindy, who had assisted us with my grandmother's ring, sat with my fiance for a couple hours, explaining different metals, colors, clarity, stone sizes, and more. Cindy has known us both by name since early September, when we brought my engagement ring in to be re-sized.

My fiance had to move out of town last month for a new job, but two weeks ago came back so we could visit Denig to look at wedding bands. My fiance, of course, found what he wanted very quickly, but I was not sure. A sample band was ordered in and I was able to try it on three business days later. Today, I called to mention I wanted to look at other bands, because I still wasn't sure which one I wanted. Cindy sat with me again today, discussing metals and looks of the bands. I decided again to consider which one I really wanted. Around 4 pm today, I received an email from Cindy with a picture and description of a different band. She also stated that she was going to do a little more research into a few more bands.

I am finally moving to our new place next week, but we will be making the trip back to Denig to order our wedding bands in a few months. In the future, Denig will absolutely be the first place (and only!) we visit when considering any type of jewelry. Cindy is always wonderful, gives her honest opinion, and seems genuinely interested in what is going on in our lives. I am so happy with my gorgeous, Scott Kay engagement ring, and we cannot wait to...

I originally visited this jeweler when I was just trying to find a place close to my house that could fix my watch band. I went in and they said they would take a look at it, and 5 minutes later returned it to me, wound, with the time and date reset (kinetic watch). Imagine my surprise when I asked them what I owed for it and they told me nothing, saying that the cost wasn't that great to them and hopefully I would come back some time. Well, little did they know I was preparing to start shopping for an engagement ring in the coming month. I came back a month later to start looking at engagement rings, visiting them as 1 of 5 stores I was shopping through. When I didn't like the first diamond that was selected, he had the next one for me to see just a few days later. They were so prompt, in fact, that the jewelry store I had been buying all my jewelry from for years didn't get back to me with their first one until I had already decided on the one from Denig. Also, to address the price and quality, with the diamond I did end up buying from Denig, I first sent the certificate to one of the other jewelers who was a family friend hoping to get a similar diamond at a lower price with the "friend" discount. The friend only replied with thanking me for the opportunity to earn my business and recommended I buy from his competitor!! That was about a year ago now and the only reason I decided to write this is because I was looking up their store hours so my fiancee and I can go look at wedding bands there later today. We're still shopping at more than one place but I'm sure like last time the others will only provide further evidence as to why I end up buying from Denig. Thanks again to the...