AJ Collectables — Local services in Greenfield

Can tell by his other responses to reviews how he treats people. Not a good place. Uneducated with very little knowledge on vintage sets or any sets in general. DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME SELLING A CARD COLLECTION TO THEM!!! Unless you bring only the best cards you have they won’t bother looking through your cards. They will just ask for your top cards. They will tell you to bring them all in and how they will go through them all and give you an offer, but they didn’t even do that. Spent more time carrying the cards into their store then they did even looking through them!! It is pure laziness. Then they had the gull to low ball an offer like I didn’t know what I had. If all they want is the top cards from any collection then they need to specify that before you bring them in. It was quite amazing how the three cards I pulled out of my boxes were worth half the offer they gave me for the entire collection. They never even saw all the great cards I do have. For instance, I have a 2021 Heritage Venezuela stamp Alec Bohm RC that was worth the offer they tried to give me and they didn’t even see this great card because they didn’t want to take any kind of time to look through and actually review all of the cards to make a reasonable offer. They also are not very knowledgeable on sets. There is more to a set than just a Hank Aaron!! Or 1970s football?! They missed out on a Rayfield Wright high numbered 1972 Topps rookie!! Why??? Because again, lazy!!! A HUGE disappointment and a waste of time. Won’t...

Some of the "bad" reviews... if not all... are obviously "not of merit / truthful"... Went in today for my 1st time after messaging a little bit with the owner/manager about some items I would like to sell for Xtra holiday cash.

I was not treated as if I knew nothing. In fact... I was invited in back while comping certain items... and Mike was an open book about comps and how the store operates with purchasing vs consignment and was upfront about what he could offer on what and why. No secret. We BOTH want to make a little money and they need room to make a little profit as well. I had numerous cards as well as many jerseys that he was interested in and asked for time to look thru all the cards. Then.. went ahead and offered me a price for a few jerseys to help me put a little money in my pocket while he went thru the cards. Staff was very friendly... place was clean and very busy as well. Personally saw some staff members stay cool while dealing with a rude customer or 2, lol. As I said, it was my 1st time.. wont be my last and I'm very curious to see whats said about my card collection.

I highly recommend this place and the shelves are absolutely stocked with lots of product for many sports. Lotsa...

Oh my god, where do I start. From all the sweet deals here and the TJ watt auto /10 to all the juiced boxes. This truly is the best card shop in Wisconsin.

The other shops and companies are so jealous that they are really giving 1 stars and making up story’s that aren’t even true. Aj is a super nice guy and same with all the other employees. They are so nice, donating cards to chairity and don’t even get me get me started with pack wars. They hit you up with free drinks and pizza and subs such a good vibe. Although I haven’t been able to make it the last couple times. The first time I ever went to one, I got a homie long signed jersey framed worth about $450 I got a derrius guice rookie prism gold base /10 sold for $130. And a mystery box valued at around $70. And a bunch of more base inserts and numbered cards. Guess how much I spent? Less then $100 no other place has this good deals, good customer service, or good and authentic products. I am so happy I found out about this shop. Because it’s the most fun I have had collecting.

Thanks for the fun memories and I hope to be back soon. To the best sports card store in Wisconsin- Aj’s...