The Paper Store — Local services in Middletown

I just had to write a glowing review! I'm guessing that all of the employees at the Paper Store in Middletown are great. I have had the good fortune of having Lyndsay help me twice. One time, was for some presents for a newborn. Tonight, Lyndsay helped me with some baptism presents. She even showed an amazing gift bag to me that is made specially for a baptism. It has a beautiful gold cross on it. Since I will be flying to the baptism, Lyndsay set me up with things that I could put in my luggage! Thank you very much Lyndsay! This is the review that I told you I would write. I love to give praise to nice people!!! 5 stars!!!!!!

OCTOBER 2022 UPDATE:: I went to the Paper Store today looking for gifts for my physical therapist and the assistant to my spine surgeon. I asked Sharon to help me. One of her suggestions was a soy candle. Not only did it smell amazing, but it had a very festive holiday top. Also -- they were on sale buy one get one free! Sharon also helped me with finding the perfect gift bags and tissue paper. THANK YOU SHARON! FIVE STARS AGAIN TO THE...

Lovely store with well-curated items as well as a robust selection of Hallmark greeting cards. The gifts and items are very diverse. You’re sure to find something for a family member or friend! As an added bonus, the store is also dog-friendly so your pup can join you while shopping! That’s very helpful since several other stores in the shopping center have a...

I had an order from Hallmark sent to this store before Christmas and they do not call or notify you. When there is an issue, they are not at all helpful, asking if I had confused their store and Barnes and Noble. Next time I will pay the postage to have my item...