Murdick's Fudge — Local services in Tisbury

I stopped in here while visiting Martha's Vineyard for the day to grab some ice cream. They had a lot of flavors (as well as a big assortment of fudge) and it was so hard to choose! We ended up getting the muddy boots, vanilla ice cream with brownie and caramel, in a cup. It came to $5 which I found pretty expensive, but I know we're in a tourist location as well as an island so it was understandable. The person inside was friendly and the store was clean. I'd recommend stopping in if you'd like...

We went to get ice cream on 7/30 night and the staff was so rude that we ended up leaving and going to get ice cream down the street. When we got to the next ice cream store, there was a group of people also talking about how rude the staff was at Murdicks which is why they also left to get ice cream elsewhere. I feel bad for the owner of the shop. They lost out on a lot of business because...

Very disappointing. Got 2 scoops of ice cream and each scoop was literally the size of a golf ball, no exaggeration finished the cone in 2-3 bites. Ice cream was very soft and almost melted when I received it. Would never spend my money on the ice...