Collectors Coins Gold Jewelry & Watch Buyers — Local services in Town of Hempstead

I’ve had the pleasure of working with Collector’s Watches several times now, and every experience has been absolutely outstanding. From start to finish, everything is smooth, professional, and handled with care. The watches are always exactly as described—high-quality, authentic pieces that any collector would be proud to own.

I’ve worked directly with Dan, and he has been phenomenal each time. His knowledge, transparency, and attention to detail make the buying process stress-free and enjoyable. Dan takes the time to answer every question, provides helpful insights, and always goes the extra mile to ensure everything is perfect.

If you’re looking for a trustworthy place to buy, sell, or trade luxury watches, I couldn’t recommend Collector’s Watches—and Dan—more highly. Every transaction has been five-star, and I’ll definitely continue to come back...

I recently inherited a nice bracelet and was curious how much I could sell it for. I went to four different coin/gold stores in Nassau County to get quotes. Unhappy with what I was being told and suspecting I was being low-balled I asked for some referrals and a person mentioned to check out Collectors Coins & Jewelry in Lynbrook. The Owner of the store is Jason and man was he top notch. I was in and out of there in 10 minutes with a check (offered me cash if I wanted instead). He beat out all other quotes I received. Just to give you an idea we parted ways at $1,350, I had received a quote at $1,280 from another store and one quote as low as $1050. Jason is professional, social, and seems extremely honest and fair too me. If I ever have jewelry, coins, or memorabilia to sell I know I'll be seeing Jason again. Thanks...

Would not use this shop for watch purchases. I made a purchase with them last May on a Cartier Tank. I asked about original parts and was told the piece was all original. Imagine my disappointment when I took it into the Cartier store for service and upon inspection, they inform me the crystal is a replacement. Either CCL was dishonest or were lied to by whomever they acquired the watch from but my gut tells me I should have known something was up when they failed to mention the spider dialing in the Chrono24 listing (details I only found after discovering higher res photos of the listing on their website). Technically I'm still within their 1yr warranty but so far have received no response from them...