Barrel Restaurant — Restaurant in Ontario

Could have been 4 stars but....

First time eating here and probably my last. The place was packed and wonderfully so, our server was friendly enough. The portions were very filling but I cannot give 4 or 5 stars for these reasons. One of our ceasar salads came out dry the dressing left well a lot to be imagined, the dressing on my salad was bland and we had to ask for more for my friend. ok no biggie. Our appetizers came out separately and the tzatziki sauce with the fried calamari was just ok, too much sour cream and no dill... um I've had better but ok.. our meals came out and 2 of us ordered the same thing, one was fully dressed with the toppings/sauce the other looked anorexic for toppings. The other dishes were fine. It came time for dessert and the variety was nice. I got mine to go (tiramisu) because I wanted a treat later. We are visiting and heres where I would have still given 4 had this not happened. The bills came split 3 ways. I pay cash and just have the server keep the change for tip, the other 2 pay in card and although we have not left yet and one didnt tip on her card but rounded up her check to the next home number and was leaving cash as its customary to tip as you leave. Rhe owner walks up to our table and asks if there was a problem because she didnt tip. We explain why figure ok no big deal but then when we do leave and the server is asked to break down a bill she doesnt break it down to give my friend the opportunity to tip what she wants she breaks down her bill by half and just keeps what she wants.. NO COOL.. I've been a server I've gotten stiffed on much larger tables than ours was (she was tipped nicely by myself and the person who did tip on their card) and forced an extra nice tip on my other friend who was trying to save her (the server) from being overly taxed by tipping cash... so in review.. food was ok, I've had better I've had worse.. prices were a little high but service was ok but tipping is not mandatory and especially what you are tip..

Oh and update the tiramisu was eh disappointing... very bland, the lady fingers were still dry the mascarpone layers were very thin.. definitely should have gotten...

I saw the billboard on highway 24 and it stuck in my mind. Got to my friends and googled, saw the pics and all the food looked yummy. We decided to give it a try. We were walking in there with pretty high expectations, which in past we have come to realize is not a good thing because then it usually falls flat on the expectation alone.

Well.... THIS PLACE DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!!!

We told our waitress first thing that we were new and from that moment on we could feel that she wanted to make sure we had a great experience. She was very personable and it was apparent she enjoyed working there as she told us she was a super long time employee and she was proud of that. Honestly, there wasn't a thing that I feel they could have done better.

Staff... all excellent from what I watched.

Menu... so perfect! Large menu with a great variety of the hometown italian classics. It was a tough choice because there was so much we wanted to try.

Food...just out of this world! We had a lasagna which had meat, it was a good portion with lots of ooey cheese and the sauce was excellent. definitely not bland. We also had the chicken with alfredo noodles and that was very flavourful and the chicken again with lots of cheese on top. We had ceasar salad, with real dressing, not from a jar. homemade. We tried the creme brulee cheesecake and the carrot cake. All absolutely excellent.

Ambiance... it was like walking into the old pizza chief. The smell alone told me I was in the right place. Everything was clean and tidy and I felt like there was a good amount of privacy at the table.

To top it off... this may not matter to some but it just made my day after living through a painful pandemic. I was just ecstatic to see all the staff come out and happily sing their rendition of a happy birthday song to someone. It was so nice to feel that normalcy all coming back and everyone actually appreciating their singing instead of the old feel of "oh man this again".

Seriously... hats off to the management and crew for creating a top notch dining experience. We will absolutely be back on a...

The Barrel Pizza and Spaghetti House is an exceptional restaurant that offers an incredible dining experience. Their stuffed mushrooms are a must-try appetizer that promises to delight your taste buds. The mushrooms are generously filled with a savory mixture and baked to perfection. Each bite is bursting with flavors that will leave you craving for more.

Moving on to the main course, the chicken marsala is a culinary masterpiece. The tender chicken is cooked to perfection and smothered in a rich marsala sauce that is both savory and slightly sweet. Paired with a side of perfectly cooked pasta, this dish is a true delight for your palate.

If you're a seafood lover, then the seafood creole at The Barrel Pizza and Spaghetti House is a dish that you absolutely cannot miss. This delightful creation combines an array of fresh seafood, from succulent shrimp to tender scallops, in a flavorful spicy tomato sauce. The dish is bursting with vibrant colors and the perfect balance of spices, making it a true feast for the senses.

In addition to their mouthwatering dishes, The Barrel Pizza and Spaghetti House also offers a warm and cozy ambiance, complemented by attentive and friendly staff. The restaurant provides a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.

Overall, The Barrel Pizza and Spaghetti House is a delightful restaurant that exceeds expectations with their outstanding stuffed mushrooms, delectable chicken marsala, and unforgettable seafood creole. Whether you're visiting for a casual meal or a special occasion, this establishment promises to provide an exceptional dining experience that will leave you...