Carefree Cakery — Restaurant in Amherst

EDITED REVIEW: Alysha and her team have once again demonstrated exceptional skill and artistry. Their ability to translate imaginative cake designs into reality is truly impressive. Recently, I commissioned a graduation cake and cupcake order for my stepson, and I was thoroughly delighted with the result. Our guests praised the cake and cupcakes, noting that they were moist, soft, and flavorful, with precisely the right level of sweetness. In the near future, I intend to place another cake order for my daughter, who will be celebrating her second birthday. I have absolute confidence in their expertise and professionalism. Beyond their evident talent and creativity, the staff consistently display a warm and friendly demeanor while maintaining impeccable professionalism.

Hands down the BEST tasting cake and cupcakes I’ve ever had. Our guests for my daughter’s 1st birthday party devoured the cake & cupcakes. Alisha was super helpful too and very professional. The cupcake toppers I ordered online were way too big, so I called her and explained the situation. She offered to order the toppers for me; some of them arrived broken but she managed to create leaves which looked so perfect at no additional cost. I am about to order another cake for my friend’s birthday. I highly...

I placed a completely customized order with this bakery for my sister's birthday with the order being completely vegan, I ordered a cake and a dozen cupcakes. I went into this order fully expecting to enjoy it that much due to the nature of vegan desserts being known for being dry and bland. Not only was the cake and cupcakes exactly how I envisioned it but that was probably some of the best cake I have ever had. It was super moist and exactly how it would taste in a normal cake. The chocolate cake was to die for and the frosting was flavorful and perfect. It was so good that even an hour after enjoying the cake my family kept talking about it giving it high praises. Even the kids loved it and made a mess with it like kids normally do. My sister, who the order was for, was very very happy and very impressed with the desserts especially since they can't enjoy normal desserts due to dietary restrictions. And when I went in to pick up my order both Alysia and her team were so welcoming and kind. This place alone made me understand why there are families and people out there have their bakeries that they are loyal too end order from for every event and holiday. Both my family and I will be coming here for our future events, birthdays,...

Carefree Cupcakes should be called Absolutely Amazing Cupcakes.... I cannot believe how amazing this cupcake was!!! If I could give it 10 stars I would. I was in the area because I had an interview to possibly teach art classes near the bakery. I stood inside the bakery debating what flavors to take home and the women behind the counter said. "I just finished making a raspberry cream frosted cupcake, would you like to try that?" It was so hard to choose just one flavor so I bought 6! When I got home I said to myself "okay I need to pick one for dessert tonight" and I so picked the raspberry creme that she brought from out back. OMG that was the best cupcake I have ever had!!! This owner whose name is Alysia Bryant knows what she is doing. I know this... I will be driving to North Amherst for all my cupcake and cake needs. Well done Alysia! It is people like you who make life much more enjoyable and...