HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Anderson

Name
Papa Johns Pizza
Description
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Nearby attractions
Northview Church - Anderson Campus
1720 E 22nd St, Anderson, IN 46016
Nearby restaurants
Anderson Grill
2038 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN 46016
Rally's
2110 IN-9, Anderson, IN 46016
McDonald's
2014 Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN 46013
China House
2128 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN 46016
Los Compadres Mexican Food Truck
2001 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN 46016
Wing On Chinese Restaurant
2320 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN 46016
Mancino's of Anderson
1606 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson, IN 46016
Wendy's
1805 State Rd 109, Anderson, IN 46016
Domino's Pizza
1827 E 18th St, Anderson, IN 46016
Subway
1904 S Scatterfield Rd Unit 6, Anderson, IN 46016
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Papa Johns Pizza tourism.Papa Johns Pizza hotels.Papa Johns Pizza bed and breakfast. flights to Papa Johns Pizza.Papa Johns Pizza attractions.Papa Johns Pizza restaurants.Papa Johns Pizza travel.Papa Johns Pizza travel guide.Papa Johns Pizza travel blog.Papa Johns Pizza pictures.Papa Johns Pizza photos.Papa Johns Pizza travel tips.Papa Johns Pizza maps.Papa Johns Pizza things to do.
Papa Johns Pizza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Papa Johns Pizza
United StatesIndianaAndersonPapa Johns Pizza

Basic Info

Papa Johns Pizza

2040 S Scatterfield Rd # C, Anderson, IN 46016
2.8(373)
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.

attractions: Northview Church - Anderson Campus, restaurants: Anderson Grill, Rally's, McDonald's, China House, Los Compadres Mexican Food Truck, Wing On Chinese Restaurant, Mancino's of Anderson, Wendy's, Domino's Pizza, Subway
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(765) 643-7272
Website
locations.papajohns.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Anderson
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Anderson
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Anderson
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Special Seasonings
dish
Anchovies
dish
Parmesan Cheese
dish
Banana Peppers
dish
Pepperoncinis
dish
Jalapeño Peppers
dish
Papadia & Drinks Bundle
dish
Boneless Wings & Drinks Bundle
dish
Cheesesticks
dish
20 Ounce Pepsi
dish
Create Your Own
dish
Oreo Papa Bites
dish
Cheese Pizza, Chztx, Brownie & Drinks
dish
Cinnamon Pull Apart
dish
Pepperoni Pizza, Brownie & Drinks Bundle
dish
8 Piece Buffalo Wings
dish
Cheesesticks
dish
Pepperoni Pizza, Chzstx, Brownie & Drinks
dish
Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
dish
Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
dish
The Works Pizza
dish
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
dish
Shaq-A-Roni Pizza
dish
BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza
dish
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
dish
Garden Fresh Pizza
dish
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
dish
The Meats Pizza
dish
Super Hawaiian Pizza
dish
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
dish
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites
dish
Jalapeño Papa Bites
dish
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites
dish
Cream Cheese Icing
dish
Spicy Garlic Sauce
dish
Cheese Sauce
dish
Blue Cheese Sauce
dish
Original Pizza Sauce
dish
Garlic Parmesan Sauce
dish
Special Garlic Sauce
dish
Barbeque Sauce
dish
Ranch Sauce
dish
Buffalo Spicy Sauce
dish
New York Style Crust
dish
Epic Stuffed Crust
dish
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust
dish
Shaq-A-Roni Pizza
dish
Create Your Own Papa Bowl
dish
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust
dish
Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
dish
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
dish
Create Your Own Pizza
dish
New York Style Crust
dish
Create Your Own Papadia
dish
BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia
dish
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Papadia
dish
Philly Cheesesteak Papadia
dish
Pepperoni Pizza
dish
Sausage Pizza
dish
Cheese Pizza
dish
Cinnamon Pull Aparts
dish
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
dish
Chocolate Chip Cookie
dish
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites
dish
Tuscan 6-Cheese Cheesesticks
dish
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites
dish
Original Breadsticks
dish
Jalapeño Papa Bites
dish
Cheesesticks
dish
Bacon Cheesesticks
dish
Garlic Knots
dish
Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks
dish
BBQ Wings
dish
BBQ Boneless Wings
dish
Honey Chipotle Boneless Wings
dish
Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings
dish
Honey Chipotle Wings
dish
Buffalo Boneless Wings
dish
Unsauced Roasted Wings
dish
Buffalo Wings
dish
Garlic Parmesan Wings
dish
Unsauced Boneless Wings
dish
Aquafina
dish
Starry
dish
Pepsi
dish
Mountain Dew
dish
Pepsi Zero Sugar
dish
Crush Orange
dish
Diet Mountain Dew

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Papa Johns Pizza

Northview Church - Anderson Campus

Northview Church - Anderson Campus

Northview Church - Anderson Campus

4.8

(45)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Ball State Mens Basketball vs. Miami (OH)
Ball State Mens Basketball vs. Miami (OH)
Sat, Dec 20 • 2:00 PM
Bethel Avenue & McKinnley Avenue,Muncie,IN,47306
View details
Monday Munchies: Muncie | Foodies + New Friends
Monday Munchies: Muncie | Foodies + New Friends
Mon, Dec 15 • 7:00 PM
South Walnut Street, Muncie, IN 47305
View details
Singles Party
Singles Party
Tue, Dec 16 • 8:00 PM
Muncie, Muncie, IN 47304
View details

Nearby restaurants of Papa Johns Pizza

Anderson Grill

Rally's

McDonald's

China House

Los Compadres Mexican Food Truck

Wing On Chinese Restaurant

Mancino's of Anderson

Wendy's

Domino's Pizza

Subway

Anderson Grill

Anderson Grill

4.4

(484)

$

Click for details
Rally's

Rally's

3.6

(839)

Click for details
McDonald's

McDonald's

3.5

(831)

Click for details
China House

China House

3.8

(138)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Reviews of Papa Johns Pizza

2.8
(373)
avatar
5.0
47w

OKAY I'm SO sick of reading this horrible complaints over small petty stuff about this store so I'm going to put my thoughts in and share my experience from last night. Hopefully people will read this and understand from my point of view as well as the employees, and STOP the complaining over every small little thing. KUDOS TO THIS PLACE AND THEIR EMPLOYEES!

I ordered here last night as I do every weekend. I'm also a Dasher who takes orders from here but I know to be patient, and if it's too long of a wait, I will unassign myself from the order. I don't do that frequently though. I wanted to relax tonight after a busy week, so I ordered from here. I don't think the other Dashers/Grub Hub/Uber drivers and carryout customers understand that they have more than one way that they get orders, and they can get orders piled up on them very quickly within a few minutes. That would be very overwhelming! Think about it; 20 orders suddenly appear and they are large orders with multiple, different items? Then another 15-20, and it keeps going. Yeah, that's stressful. Everyone yelling, cussing, and throwing an attitude doesn't help, so if you're reading this, please don't do that. Don't do it to anyone in fast food or restaurants, or anywhere. Be patient and have compassion. Day-shift helps to prepare them for this. I've watched them in action and heard the conversations. For me, the call center said a 15-20 minute wait, but I know the call center is not based in the USA and there is no way that you're going to get a carry out from a popular, busy pizza place in that time on weekends or holidays. Common sense should tell you that.

I gave them time to get my order ready as I was busy at the time anyway. Getting inside was horrible as the lobby was packed, but that was not the employees fault. They can only do so much. I had a 45 minute wait, and yes, the assistant manager at the cut table had pizza's piling up on him but he was doing a fantastic job. But the guys making the pizza's were staying on top of it, too. A few times they had to hold off to give him a chance to fix things up. The young guy who also runs the register was constantly going back and forth filling up boxes and putting the labels on them, and the older guy was constantly bringing up what was called out that was needed. So you can't say they were lazy and unorganized.

There were two ladies who were sorting everyone's orders; one eventually had taken the orders to the side and was helping with cutting and making sure everything was put together. If I recall right, this is the hearing impaired pregnant lady who works day-shift with her husband (the assistant manager) and is due to have a baby soon. So she had been there since the store opened. At 9:30pm she was still there working hard just like the rest of them. Talk about dedication and determination, wow! The other lady was handing the customers and the orders, and had been cussed out multiple times and was on the verge of tears. They finally had to move everything in the back to clear room for the assistant manager and to get the orders together to give out.

The nice young gentleman who took their spot was helping customers with orders, offering and giving refunds and discounts for wait time, and running to the back and grabbing orders as fast as he could. I did see the pregnant lady come through and try to squeeze through saying something about an urgent issue due to her GM about to pass out. I finally got my order, and yes it actually was fresh, everything was there, I did end up with something extra that wasn't mine and called to let them know. I also was offered a refund but I didn't take it because I felt they deserved the money. Plus my order was correct and fresh.

I feel that everyone who worked last night did their part to the best of their ability, just like I always see when I'm in there. Great job, Papa John's Anderson! You did very well! I'm sorry people are rude...

   Read more
avatar
5.0
51w

I want to praise this team. I order from here a lot and also pick up doordash and uber orders. Yes it can get busy with a wait on weekends, but that is because they get hit with huge orders unexpectedly. The weather, the football games, the sales that are offered play a part and large orders that come in through multiple sources smash them at once. The crew does do the best they can do on both shifts. The morning crew is very pleasant to deal with and have less wait time because of the male assistant manager and the really nice lady who is hard of hearing that works with him. I do know they work way past their shifts because I see them late at night a lot. Customers have complained about her ignoring them, but they don't know she's very hard of hearing. I have interacted with her, she is a lip reader and tries to hear with what seems to be her better hearing side. With all of the noise in the back, it's hard for her. When she's there at night, it's even harder because it's louder due to more customers being in the lobby. But she's fast and does her job well. At least she works and does multiple things at once. She does try to interact with customers. It's a shame that customers treat her poorly. Night shift seems to be fun to interact with also. You can tell they are doing the best that they can to keep up with all of the orders. They try to keep a pleasant, upbeat atmosphere while being focused on doing their jobs. I picked up my latest order as carryout. I expected a wait and was surprised that my order was done as quick as it was. No mess ups, looks and tastes great! I wish others would understand that these are humans working, there is no need to yell at them. It only stresses them out worse and you take up time that they could be dedicating to getting the orders out to others, mostly you. The customers yelling and cussing at this staff need to be more patient and understand they are doing what they can. Stop being rude to them and have some patience and grace with them. Yes, there bound to be mistakes but what company doesn't make a mistake? Do you make mistakes? We all do, so why all the dramatics and hate placed on this place? The GM they have now is doing a great job with the staff that he has, he is pleasant to work with, the morning assistant is "not on drugs" as I've read from others. I wish people would stop assuming that based on how a person speaks. You can't really tell that the hard of hearing lady even is hearing impaired by her speech. You can if you listen close enough, and if you watch her eyes, you can tell she's trying to read your lips and that's why she looks like she has a deer in headlights look. If the assistant was "on drugs and slurring" then tell me why his morning shifts run so smooth and on time with barely any mistakes? The crew is getting much better at...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
4y

Tonight was the absolute worst experience I've ever had with a restaurant. Hands down!! It took over two and a half hours to get our pizza's. They all were cold, pepperoni pizza's barley had any pepperoni. The cheese on the cheese pizza was hard. I had to feed my kid's before any food ever arrived. They were tired and hungry, we have 4 kid's and tonight we also had our granddaughter. When we called Papa John's, the phone just rang and rang. The driver finally showed up, we ordered at 8:00p.m, it was 10:15p.m. My husband said, I really hope our pizza's aren't cold after this long or I'm not tipping.To whice the driver said, there's a credit card tip!! I always tip in cash, always! I absolutely, 100% did NOT put a credit card tip. I had cash on my counter for the driver already. My husband was hungry and had some of the cold works pizza. Two bites into his second piece, he threw up. After close to 3 hours after we originally ordered, I threw all 4 pizza's in the trash. I didn't bother to call the store to speak to a manager, because between my experience tonight, all the terrible reviews I seen AFTER my service and the fact that they never answered when we called to check on our order, it's clear that it would do no good. IF they were to make thing's right, our pizza's wouldn't have arrived until the next day. Then after the driver left I seen I had a missed call and a voice-mail. It was the delivery driver he said, "this is your driver from door dash". I didn't order through door dash, I've never used door dash, EVER!! I ordered right from the Papa John's online app. I'll be calling the corporate office tomorrow. This experience was totally unacceptable! Tip's being added to my check without my approval, food was a total loss, 5 hungry, tired and crying kid's, $40 plus for absolutely nothing but aggravation and...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Geoffrey PepperGeoffrey Pepper
This is probably the 6th "Oops" card they have sent us in 2 months. We have had issue after issue, I can't for the life of me understand the issues at this store. The pizza comes with either next to no toppings, like our 6 pepperoni pizza we received a few weeks back, or it is (the most common issue) pizza that is on over proofed dough that hasn't been properly docked (if at all) and stretched to a size that it wasn't intended to be like a medium dough made into a large, or the pizza has taken like 75-90 minutes to head out for delivery and the app keeps pushing back the ETA for delivery 30 minutes at a time. Like we don't use Door Dash so why is it OK to make us wait for a Dasher or expect us to be ok with a Dasher that is doing like multiple stops and pickups between your store and my home? If I wanted to waste my time with that noise I would order on DoorDash and not from you guys.. but have you any clue what over proofed and over stretched dough looks like??? Here's a pic for you, pizza too thin in the middle and bubbled out of shape but again so thin EVERYTHING slides off all over you as you try to eat it! I used to be a manager at this store like 12-13 yrs ago and the ONLY reason I bother ordering is my autistic 8 yr old will only eat McDonald's and Papa John's... the couple nights a week I have her we are forced to endure this sub par service. Perhaps I should just start driving to Pendleton, since they are a different franchise, Muncie is also owned by Bajco and religiously offers the same issues. This is a shame because I can remember when this didn't fly at that store... I would hate to think my quitting to get a better job would run a business to such poor operational standards.
Brenda SheetsBrenda Sheets
HONESTLY DESERVE ZERO . I RECEIVED TEXT MY $31.00 ORDER WAS DONE. WENT IN TOTAL IGNORED . EVEN THOUGH MADE EYE CONTACT . TOLD HIM MY NAME . HE SAID HE HAD NO ORDER UNDER THIS NAME . WENT OUT TO MY CAR SHOWED HIM MY TEXT . HE SAID ANGRY IM THE ONLY ONE HERE . ?? I WAS VERY NICE I CANT AFFORD TO GO OUT TO EAT VERY OFTEN . LAST TIME CAME IN RECEIVED SAME NO SMILE GREETING AS TODAY . IVE WORKED IN RETAIL CUSTOMER SERVICE ALL MY LIFE . I WAS VERY KIND PATIENT . HE WAS NOT . ALL FOOD WAS DISGUSTING IT WENT IN TRASH .AND IVE WORKED IN BAKERY DELI ALSO . WE WERE REQUIRED TO WEAR GLOVES . NEVER HAVE SEEN ANY EMPLOYEES WEARING GLOVES EVER HE WENT TO GETTING PIZZA DOUGH WITH NO GLOVES TO TAKING MY MONEY TO GO BACK TO TOUCHING FOOD INGREDIENTS WITHOUT WASHING HANDS OR EVEN GLOVES . THIS EXACTLY WHY ILL NEVER BE BACK . ID RATHER DRIVE 30 MINUTES TO BETTER CLEANER CUSTOMER SERVICE .
Kaitlin WagnerKaitlin Wagner
I ordered from DoorDash because this location doesn’t deliver to me. $30 BEFORE tip for a small Hawaiian and small cheese bread. The quality was horrible. Somehow when they baked them, all the toppings either fell off or shifted to one side. So only half of each item had toppings on it. Someone took these out of the oven, looked at them and boxed them anyway. Complained to DoorDash and got $7 refunded, which barely covered the tip. 100% not worth the money, very disappointing.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Anderson

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

This is probably the 6th "Oops" card they have sent us in 2 months. We have had issue after issue, I can't for the life of me understand the issues at this store. The pizza comes with either next to no toppings, like our 6 pepperoni pizza we received a few weeks back, or it is (the most common issue) pizza that is on over proofed dough that hasn't been properly docked (if at all) and stretched to a size that it wasn't intended to be like a medium dough made into a large, or the pizza has taken like 75-90 minutes to head out for delivery and the app keeps pushing back the ETA for delivery 30 minutes at a time. Like we don't use Door Dash so why is it OK to make us wait for a Dasher or expect us to be ok with a Dasher that is doing like multiple stops and pickups between your store and my home? If I wanted to waste my time with that noise I would order on DoorDash and not from you guys.. but have you any clue what over proofed and over stretched dough looks like??? Here's a pic for you, pizza too thin in the middle and bubbled out of shape but again so thin EVERYTHING slides off all over you as you try to eat it! I used to be a manager at this store like 12-13 yrs ago and the ONLY reason I bother ordering is my autistic 8 yr old will only eat McDonald's and Papa John's... the couple nights a week I have her we are forced to endure this sub par service. Perhaps I should just start driving to Pendleton, since they are a different franchise, Muncie is also owned by Bajco and religiously offers the same issues. This is a shame because I can remember when this didn't fly at that store... I would hate to think my quitting to get a better job would run a business to such poor operational standards.
Geoffrey Pepper

Geoffrey Pepper

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Anderson

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
HONESTLY DESERVE ZERO . I RECEIVED TEXT MY $31.00 ORDER WAS DONE. WENT IN TOTAL IGNORED . EVEN THOUGH MADE EYE CONTACT . TOLD HIM MY NAME . HE SAID HE HAD NO ORDER UNDER THIS NAME . WENT OUT TO MY CAR SHOWED HIM MY TEXT . HE SAID ANGRY IM THE ONLY ONE HERE . ?? I WAS VERY NICE I CANT AFFORD TO GO OUT TO EAT VERY OFTEN . LAST TIME CAME IN RECEIVED SAME NO SMILE GREETING AS TODAY . IVE WORKED IN RETAIL CUSTOMER SERVICE ALL MY LIFE . I WAS VERY KIND PATIENT . HE WAS NOT . ALL FOOD WAS DISGUSTING IT WENT IN TRASH .AND IVE WORKED IN BAKERY DELI ALSO . WE WERE REQUIRED TO WEAR GLOVES . NEVER HAVE SEEN ANY EMPLOYEES WEARING GLOVES EVER HE WENT TO GETTING PIZZA DOUGH WITH NO GLOVES TO TAKING MY MONEY TO GO BACK TO TOUCHING FOOD INGREDIENTS WITHOUT WASHING HANDS OR EVEN GLOVES . THIS EXACTLY WHY ILL NEVER BE BACK . ID RATHER DRIVE 30 MINUTES TO BETTER CLEANER CUSTOMER SERVICE .
Brenda Sheets

Brenda Sheets

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Anderson

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

I ordered from DoorDash because this location doesn’t deliver to me. $30 BEFORE tip for a small Hawaiian and small cheese bread. The quality was horrible. Somehow when they baked them, all the toppings either fell off or shifted to one side. So only half of each item had toppings on it. Someone took these out of the oven, looked at them and boxed them anyway. Complained to DoorDash and got $7 refunded, which barely covered the tip. 100% not worth the money, very disappointing.
Kaitlin Wagner

Kaitlin Wagner

See more posts
See more posts