I never write reviews without being asked, but I’m so impressed with my experience that I have to share. It was the week of Thanksgiving, and I needed to still find a “fun” cake for my son’s birthday after Thanksgiving. Susie’s allowed for an online order for a custom cake to be ready the upcoming Sunday. Other bakeries were blocked off or didn’t have an efficient/easy ordering experience. (In the future Susie’s will be my first choice! I just didn’t know about them yet.) We got the Rainbow Sprinkle Cake, 9” with chocolate layers inside. It was chocolate cake with 6 chocolate buttercream layers in between. It allowed me to personalize the top for my son’s birthday. (The writing was written with white icing on top of the sprinkles, so don’t make it too wordy. I kept it to three words and it looked great.) In retrospect, for our party of about 20 people, we should’ve gone with the smaller 6” cake because it’s still a LOT of cake! Every slice you can basically turn into two slices because of the height of the cake. Everyone was so amazed by the cake with how it looked AND tasted. I couldn’t wait to sneak another slice the next day! Thanks, SusieCakes, for helping make my son’s birthday...
Read moreOctober 2025
Got my free slice of cake for my birthday and took home some Halloween cookies. The staff is always very friendly and love their cakes and have a great selection including seasonal items.
September 2024
There was a birthday in the house and perfect time to try SusieCakes. I went online and setup my new SusieCakes account and the app too. I ordered the 6" Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake with sprinkles on top.
The next day I went to the bakery to pick it up. The staff was super friendly and have cakes, cupcakes and other treats on display. You can buy a slice of cake too. They also sell accessories like napkins, plates and numeric candles. My order was ready to pickup. I also got a free cupcake for setting up an account and purchased a second one. It was a Chocolate and Vanilla Blue. Both tasted really good with great soft flavor. The cake was just delicious and very chocolatey.
I will definitely return for...
Read moreMy new favorite bakery in town, and DEFINITELY for any of my upcoming parties or events!
I called SusieCakes to see if they could create some custom buttercream cupcakes for me, and Lexie was soooo sweet in helping me get exactly what I needed to make my celebration perfect, and when I needed it ready too!
When I arrived, she and another gal were so excited to help me get my cupcakes packaged for my event and made sure they stayed fresh and delicious for my guests. The customer service is just so amazing I wouldn't want to go anywhere else for my baked goods.
My guests raved about how incredible the cupcakes were (all asking where I got them), and I gladly shared my new find. I plan to come back for the delicious...
Read more