West Eden Pizza — Restaurant in Bar Harbor

Been here a few times. Staff are nice and the pizza is excellent, no complaints

All the same, I got short-changed the other day in terms of size. Ordered a 16'' pizza. It came to $22.68 with tax. Got home and discovered the supposedly 16'' pie was barely 14'' in diameter. Surface-wise, that's a difference of almost 50 square inches. (To be precise, I got 154 square inches at best...and paid for 201 square inches. So that's a quarter of my pizza that just "vanished." Not cool at all.)

See photo. The box interior is exactly 16 inches side to side. The pizza, not so much.

Probably an honest mistake. Next time, though, I'm going to open the box right at the cash register and verify that I'm receiving the amount of food I ordered and am paying for. I suggest you do the same. Life is expensive enough without...

This is perhaps the best pizza place on the island. The crust is cooked beautifully with just the right amount of crispiness. The sauce is nearly perfect, not sugary sweet, not loaded with musty Italian seasoning like some other local pizza places. The pizza chef uses the right amount of cheese. The last place I had pizza this good was in South Florida. It's even better than Pat's Pizza, which is a state favorite. The chef is very consistent too, each time the pizza is the same quality. In addition to pizza, they make really good sandwiches and appetizers. I would recommend The Reverend sandwich. They make lovely cannoli too, but be sure to show up early because they make small batches, and they sell out fast. All the food is made fresh, with consistent quality. Highly recommend...

This is not your average pizza place (or what counts for average in central Massachusetts where we come from) My family arrived at a rental on a Saturday and since we still needed to shop for the week when it got to be dinner time I looked for a place close by that was still open. I ordered from West Eden through Square and it wasn't until I got the confirmation text that I learned it would take 45 minutes to be ready. Like I said, the average pizza place where I come from can complete an order in about 20 minutes. So, not sure if the staff was having an off night, and the pizza I had was pretty good, but I would recommend that if an order for 4 people is going to take more than 20 minutes, or orders are backed up, there should be a clear message before an...