HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Pizza On The Bay — Restaurant in Caseville

Name
Pizza On The Bay
Description
Nearby attractions
Caseville Historical Society
6733 Prospect St, Caseville, MI 48725
Nearby restaurants
Dairy Queen Store
6395 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
Thumb Brewery
6758 Pine St, Caseville, MI 48725
Blue Water Inn
6584 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
Beachy's
6567B Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
Giuseppe's Pizza Restaurant
6562 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
Walt's Restaurant
6618 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
MQS Pizza Express
6631 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
Shakers Ice Cream Parlor
6685 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
Wooded Island Sports Grill
6868 Michigan Ave, Caseville, MI 48725
Nearby hotels
Rainbow Motel
6850 Division St #9624, Caseville, MI 48725
Related posts
Keywords
Pizza On The Bay tourism.Pizza On The Bay hotels.Pizza On The Bay bed and breakfast. flights to Pizza On The Bay.Pizza On The Bay attractions.Pizza On The Bay restaurants.Pizza On The Bay travel.Pizza On The Bay travel guide.Pizza On The Bay travel blog.Pizza On The Bay pictures.Pizza On The Bay photos.Pizza On The Bay travel tips.Pizza On The Bay maps.Pizza On The Bay things to do.
Pizza On The Bay things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Pizza On The Bay
United StatesMichiganCasevillePizza On The Bay

Basic Info

Pizza On The Bay

6400 Main St, Caseville, MI 48725
4.3(94)
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: Caseville Historical Society, restaurants: Dairy Queen Store, Thumb Brewery, Blue Water Inn, Beachy's, Giuseppe's Pizza Restaurant, Walt's Restaurant, MQS Pizza Express, Shakers Ice Cream Parlor, Wooded Island Sports Grill
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(989) 856-2242
Website
facebook.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Caseville
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Caseville
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Caseville
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
3-Cheese
Iggies Bread
Mozzarella Cheese Bread
(Small, large)
5-Piece
Boneless or bone-in
10-Piece
Boneless or bone-in

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Pizza On The Bay

Caseville Historical Society

Caseville Historical Society

Caseville Historical Society

4.8

(32)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Nearby restaurants of Pizza On The Bay

Dairy Queen Store

Thumb Brewery

Blue Water Inn

Beachy's

Giuseppe's Pizza Restaurant

Walt's Restaurant

MQS Pizza Express

Shakers Ice Cream Parlor

Wooded Island Sports Grill

Dairy Queen Store

Dairy Queen Store

4.3

(135)

$

Click for details
Thumb Brewery

Thumb Brewery

4.4

(364)

$

Click for details
Blue Water Inn

Blue Water Inn

4.0

(416)

Click for details
Beachy's

Beachy's

4.4

(124)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Posts

K RK R
DISGUSTING & SO RUDE….I would've been a 1st time customer tonight. Went to pick up my preordered food and as I waited for it, I noticed no gloves being worn by the teen boy preparing the pizzas- He wiped his nose, finger combed his hair away from his eyes, touched the handle on the walk-in fridge, and wiped his face again once he got back in front of his station and proceeded to stick his hand in the toppings unwashed and no gloves! Meanwhile, the blonde woman (I’m assuming the owner) was back by the pizza oven w/her long blonde hair blowing all around, from the fan pointed at her w/out a hairtie in. She proceeded to cut and box pizzas as they came out of the oven. As the boy started to make my salad still “ungloved”, I politely apologized for the being “that person” and asked if they could please remake my food w/gloves and hair pulled back. All staff stepped away from their stations, walked into a side office space for roughly 15 minutes to mock and laugh at my request and look up the law on their phones (I could hear them and my son could see them thru the window in front of the building) then came back to tell me they would not remake my food because they aren’t required to wear gloves because the pizza goes thru the hot oven. I asked what about the salad and the woman pulling her hair back. The other teen, at the register had nothing to say except smirk and repeat that I could take the food “as is” or leave it. Although the health dept doesn’t require gloves to be warn they along with the FDA do advise it is of best practice to wear gloves and hair IS LEGALLY supposed to be put up! Why would you not want to display the best food safety practices at your establishment? Especially when requested?! Based on some other reviews, hygienic/food safety practices doesn’t seem to be a priority at this pizza spot as others have had similar complaints... Not only did the owner (assuming she was) send a teen boy to represent her establishment but he also mocked my request to my face (as if it was the most absurd thing to ask for…Hello, I will be eating it and I will be the one getting possibly sick! Nor do I want hair in my food! Covid still does exist and contamination is real!!) but while I exited the building he proceeded to obnoxiously yell, “BYE” repeatedly until I made it out the door! How they have stayed in business for years is beside me! If you want grubby contaminated hands and hair in your pizza, this is the spot!!!
G thecomedianG thecomedian
This is a really good pizza place. The toppings are kinda bland or whatever but that doesn't take away from how awesome that crust is. Its crunchy, chewy and garlic buttery. The place was full of people waiting for pizza. I ordered 2 medium pizzas and the guy said 15 mins. I didn't believe him, but sure enough, that's all it took. I was surprised and impressed. Truth be told I had low expectations for this place. After today, I can definitely say, this is a really good pizza joint. I can't wait to try their other items.
D. CampbellD. Campbell
One of the best pizzas and bread sticks I've ever had. Not sure how a small town pizza place did it but they did. If you like alot cheese on a perfectly baked pie this is the place. The bread sticks where even better perfectly cook a little crispy with a great garlic butter. Did not try the deep dish just a regular large 3 top pizza. Did not expect to give a 5 star when ordering. Love stumbling upon a hidden gem. I would recommend. will be back next year
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Caseville

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

DISGUSTING & SO RUDE….I would've been a 1st time customer tonight. Went to pick up my preordered food and as I waited for it, I noticed no gloves being worn by the teen boy preparing the pizzas- He wiped his nose, finger combed his hair away from his eyes, touched the handle on the walk-in fridge, and wiped his face again once he got back in front of his station and proceeded to stick his hand in the toppings unwashed and no gloves! Meanwhile, the blonde woman (I’m assuming the owner) was back by the pizza oven w/her long blonde hair blowing all around, from the fan pointed at her w/out a hairtie in. She proceeded to cut and box pizzas as they came out of the oven. As the boy started to make my salad still “ungloved”, I politely apologized for the being “that person” and asked if they could please remake my food w/gloves and hair pulled back. All staff stepped away from their stations, walked into a side office space for roughly 15 minutes to mock and laugh at my request and look up the law on their phones (I could hear them and my son could see them thru the window in front of the building) then came back to tell me they would not remake my food because they aren’t required to wear gloves because the pizza goes thru the hot oven. I asked what about the salad and the woman pulling her hair back. The other teen, at the register had nothing to say except smirk and repeat that I could take the food “as is” or leave it. Although the health dept doesn’t require gloves to be warn they along with the FDA do advise it is of best practice to wear gloves and hair IS LEGALLY supposed to be put up! Why would you not want to display the best food safety practices at your establishment? Especially when requested?! Based on some other reviews, hygienic/food safety practices doesn’t seem to be a priority at this pizza spot as others have had similar complaints... Not only did the owner (assuming she was) send a teen boy to represent her establishment but he also mocked my request to my face (as if it was the most absurd thing to ask for…Hello, I will be eating it and I will be the one getting possibly sick! Nor do I want hair in my food! Covid still does exist and contamination is real!!) but while I exited the building he proceeded to obnoxiously yell, “BYE” repeatedly until I made it out the door! How they have stayed in business for years is beside me! If you want grubby contaminated hands and hair in your pizza, this is the spot!!!
K R

K R

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Caseville

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
This is a really good pizza place. The toppings are kinda bland or whatever but that doesn't take away from how awesome that crust is. Its crunchy, chewy and garlic buttery. The place was full of people waiting for pizza. I ordered 2 medium pizzas and the guy said 15 mins. I didn't believe him, but sure enough, that's all it took. I was surprised and impressed. Truth be told I had low expectations for this place. After today, I can definitely say, this is a really good pizza joint. I can't wait to try their other items.
G thecomedian

G thecomedian

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Caseville

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

One of the best pizzas and bread sticks I've ever had. Not sure how a small town pizza place did it but they did. If you like alot cheese on a perfectly baked pie this is the place. The bread sticks where even better perfectly cook a little crispy with a great garlic butter. Did not try the deep dish just a regular large 3 top pizza. Did not expect to give a 5 star when ordering. Love stumbling upon a hidden gem. I would recommend. will be back next year
D. Campbell

D. Campbell

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Pizza On The Bay

4.3
(94)
avatar
1.0
22w

DISGUSTING & SO RUDE….I would've been a 1st time customer tonight. Went to pick up my preordered food and as I waited for it, I noticed no gloves being worn by the teen boy preparing the pizzas- He wiped his nose, finger combed his hair away from his eyes, touched the handle on the walk-in fridge, and wiped his face again once he got back in front of his station and proceeded to stick his hand in the toppings unwashed and no gloves! Meanwhile, the blonde woman (I’m assuming the owner) was back by the pizza oven w/her long blonde hair blowing all around, from the fan pointed at her w/out a hairtie in. She proceeded to cut and box pizzas as they came out of the oven. As the boy started to make my salad still “ungloved”, I politely apologized for the being “that person” and asked if they could please remake my food w/gloves and hair pulled back. All staff stepped away from their stations, walked into a side office space for roughly 15 minutes to mock and laugh at my request and look up the law on their phones (I could hear them and my son could see them thru the window in front of the building) then came back to tell me they would not remake my food because they aren’t required to wear gloves because the pizza goes thru the hot oven. I asked what about the salad and the woman pulling her hair back. The other teen, at the register had nothing to say except smirk and repeat that I could take the food “as is” or leave it. Although the health dept doesn’t require gloves to be warn they along with the FDA do advise it is of best practice to wear gloves and hair IS LEGALLY supposed to be put up! Why would you not want to display the best food safety practices at your establishment? Especially when requested?! Based on some other reviews, hygienic/food safety practices doesn’t seem to be a priority at this pizza spot as others have had similar complaints... Not only did the owner (assuming she was) send a teen boy to represent her establishment but he also mocked my request to my face (as if it was the most absurd thing to ask for…Hello, I will be eating it and I will be the one getting possibly sick! Nor do I want hair in my food! Covid still does exist and contamination is real!!) but while I exited the building he proceeded to obnoxiously yell, “BYE” repeatedly until I made it out the door! How they have stayed in business for years is beside me! If you want grubby contaminated hands and hair in your pizza, this...

   Read more
avatar
4.0
2y

This is a really good pizza place. The toppings are kinda bland or whatever but that doesn't take away from how awesome that crust is. Its crunchy, chewy and garlic buttery. The place was full of people waiting for pizza. I ordered 2 medium pizzas and the guy said 15 mins. I didn't believe him, but sure enough, that's all it took. I was surprised and impressed. Truth be told I had low expectations for this place. After today, I can definitely say, this is a really good pizza joint. I can't wait to try their...

   Read more
avatar
5.0
9y

ricordi un paio d'olore sogno volevo sapere pericoloso nonostante le cose vanno male lontanamente penso proprio come senti Malè di tutto ciò tranquilla zone conosci memoria interna ed esterna rompere gli amicizia logelosia nel caso avessi bisogno ti nin lascio è per che cosa significare tutto benes ma perché vorrei sapere adessi usami nin detto mai più di te occuparsene dimme tra le varie fasi della mia vita è troppo tardi fai da te mimanchi Pasquale Ivan del Giordano è Valeria puzo Teresa russo piccolina Ilaria belgianni Giusy belgianni luigi onorato è Nicola onorato piccolino anche tu vieni da me i segreti delle cose personale docente ed educativo ed amicizia con te spavento ho paura di perdere tempo realtà sono indicati nel settore delle cose da te ne vai via dei problemi più belle di chi sia possibile approfittando un sogno nel cassetto non ci siamo detti al confine orientale che ne dici tu giovane talento cantante inglese per l'attenzione sulla spiacente non fosse possibilità sbagliato qualcosa qualche qualcuno dimme che ha le idee vero l'amore con gli occhi aperti conoscenza degli annunci casomai rompere gli insieme ad abbandonare le palle da accordo conoscere meglio i cari amici di famigly bracciale Porto fortuna amicizia tra me e te li porto il quale ha avuto? soffrire per lascia stare con voi avete già fatti sentire ogni tipo innamorai dimme tra le cose più tardi allora si trattare i cari saluti da parte mia...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next