Thumb Brewery — Restaurant in Caseville

Oh my lord is this place over-priced. There is basically nothing on the menu but flat breads and burgers. The burgers were low quality and way over-cooked. My mother ordered a glass of wine and we all agreed that the pour looked very small but it wasn't until the lady next to us was served a glass that was twice the size in pour, served by the owner himself, that we said something. They took it off and our server Jeff was efficient and nice. However, we get that you're seasonal and have to make your money when you can but build on so that you have more seating inside during the cold months and then you can stop ripping people off. $16 for a cheeseburger with no fries!?!!? If you want to add fries it's $3:50?! That's $19.50 for an over cooked Bubba burger w/fries! Absolutely unacceptable. We have never felt so ripped off spending $175 for 3 adults and 3 kids and we will NEVER EVER BE BACK AND PLAN TO WARN EVERYONE TO STEER CLEAR OF THIS ROBBERY OF A FAILING ESTABLISHMENT! For the idiots that think this is a fair deal, you really need to get...

We arrived mid afternoon, for a late lunch. The wait quoted was very long, but expected due to staffing issues most restaurants are experiencing. We were seated outdoors, when I asked for indoor seating due to threat of imminent rain, I was told I’d be moved if it started raining. It did, we were moved after only getting a little wet.

Hubby ordered a burger, I ordered a flat bread. I was completely finished eating by the time his burger arrived. It was cold. He was starving and we just wanted to get going, so he ate it. We had been there close to an hour at this point. We waited another twenty minutes before we could get our servers attention. He walked by several times, but never seemed to see our signals or hear us call his name so we could ask for the check. Only a couple of their own brewed beers were available hubby tried one, liked it. I ordered a cocktail which was just ok. Didn’t expect much when ordering a cocktail from a brewery. Food was decent, if it had been hot.

Staff was friendly enough, but things seemed very...

Came here for dinner last night and it was such a great experience. We ordered the three cheese artichoke dip, shrimp scampi pasta, and BBQ Brisket sandwich. My husband got a beer… one of the IPAs, I’m unsure of the name! It was all delicious! Highly recommend the dip with the fresh baguette! 👌👍 If you’re going for dinner, I suggest getting there early as it got very packed even a little before 6pm on a Friday night! There was live music playing and the musician was good to boot! Huge shout to Lauren for her accommodations (we had a baby and stroller in a small and busy space) as she quickly shifted tables and other things around for us to be comfortable. She even had the musician give us an anniversary shout on the mic. It made us feel very special. It looks like there is a lot of outdoor seating and I’m sure it would be a different but equally wonderful experience in the warmer months also. If we’re ever in the thumb again (love their brewery name, too haha) we will have to make this a stop! Thank you, Thumb Brewery staff,...