Benny Montanaro's Pizza — Restaurant in Casper

RANT!! Benny’s Pizza!

It’s a novelty I get it super large slices of pizza. The sauce is too sweet but the crust is good and the toppings are good. It’s still not my favorite pizza. What pisses me off is when I stop by on a Monday night at 7:15 and the doors locked and there’s two people inside joking around and I knock on the door and I point to the hours posted on the door that says 8 o’clock!! I just wanted one slice of pizza. This is the problem today with people not wanting to work. Everything says 8 o’clock then close your doors at 8 o’clock…

Clearly I Should’ve gone to Firehouse

To answer your question I’ve eaten probably a dozen times… the sauce has to much sugar but that’s a personal preference I know many people outside of NY like a sweet sauce.

Had to close early? Why wasn’t something posted? Why are others saying this has happened to them. No need to make anything right.. I’m a conservative - I’ll take my...

My husband and I have gotten this pizza several times. And normally we get it delivered. It has been our favorite pizza place here in Casper. Anytime family comes to town we have to take them here. However today was not the case. This time I decided to get it after I got off work. I ordered the pizza in the store, waited for nearly 30 minutes. When I went to ask the status of my pizza, I got asked what toppings were, the guys looks around for said pizza. And was sitting on top of the oven for at least 10 minutes. Nothing was announced that it was ready just sitting up there. I was annoyed because I was ready to go home. All I got in return was, oh sorry. No offer for anything off my pizza next time. No offers of a drink. No offers of a dipping sauce. Nothing. It will be long time before I think about going into the store to...

It says on the website that the pizza is 28", but it doesn't really compute until the little delivery gal shows up with this ridiculously too big box.

I mean... I knew it was big, but wow! For a single guy like me, there's enough food in one pizza for a whole week.

One slice is an entire meal. I tried to put the left overs in a gallon ziploc bag, but they wouldn't fit.

Good news is the pizza tastes great. Super foldable but solid enough it doesn't fall apart. Sauce is good. Dough is good.

If I ever have a party or something, this would be perfect. Save yourself and just order it by...