Goody’s Pizza — Restaurant in Cinnaminson Township

We finally ordered from this place to try it out but went through an annoying experience with a delivery. We waited over an hour and finally called to check on it. They were insisting that it was dropped off at our house when it wasn't at either our front or back door. They went on to talk about their driver having a Tesla/ being very accurate and that they would never lie about dropping off a delivery (we never said anyone was lying) as though they think we were lying about not receiving it. They also suggested our food had gotten stolen. It turns out, the very "accurate" driver delivered to the wrong house and the food had been sitting out for about 40 minutes. Food for thought: Your customers are just trying to resolve an issue, and it would be nice to realize that mistakes happen BEFORE assuming they are lying about not receiving...

If you’re excited that goody’s is back because you missed the chicken fingers as much as we did, I’m sad to report that we were told on the phone they are no longer the hand breaded tenders of the past (although we didn’t try them to be able to rate). We had a vodka chicken pizza and the pizza was tasty, the crust was good but it was definitely an overloaded saucey pizza that was floppy as a result. We determined that the pizza was not something we’d order again, but also wouldn’t complain if someone else ordered it. Definitely more than edible. The cheesesteak was very basic for the price, nothing to write home about, although the sesame seeded roll is a nice touch. Goody’s staff—bring back the handmade, hand breaded giant tenders and you’ll have us as...

Honestly an unexpected, amazing experience. I came in with low expectations and was blown away. I had the Big Phil, a Buffalo chicken tender Sammie with bacon and provolone on a toasted seeded roll. This sandwich was MASSIVE. Not to mention their small fries putting others large to shame. The food was excellent. Perfectly cooked, seasoned and sauced. If I lived in NJ I would spend so much money here if the rest of the menu is half as good as this. Not to mention the whole establishment is so clean. Did not expect this from a strip mall food stop. 10/10 if you're around drop in; I bet you won't be...