Main Street Pizza Company — Restaurant in City of Batavia

My wife and I recently visited Main Street pizza company, and we were blown away by the incredible dining experience we had. We were in the mood for pizza, and after reading rave reviews online, we decided to try their deep dish pepperoni pizza. It was a decision we did not regret.

From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm welcome and seated promptly. Our server, Maria, was attentive and knowledgeable, and she helped us choose a bottle of red wine that perfectly complemented our meal.

When the pizza arrived at our table, we were immediately struck by its size and presentation. It was a beautiful sight to behold - a golden crust, layered with gooey cheese and savory pepperoni, all perfectly arranged in a deep dish.

As we took our first bites, we were both amazed by the incredible flavor and texture. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft and doughy on the inside, with just the right amount of chewiness. The cheese was melted to perfection, and the pepperoni was generously spread throughout the pizza.

The sauce was the star of the show, though. It was thick and tangy, with just the right amount of sweetness and spice. Every bite was a perfect balance of flavors, and we could not stop raving about how delicious it was.

Throughout the meal, Maria, our server was attentive and friendly, ensuring that we had everything we needed to enjoy our dining experience to the fullest. The atmosphere of the restaurant was cozy and welcoming, with soft lighting and comfortable seating.

When it came time for dessert, we were pleasantly surprised by the range of options available. We decided to try the tiramisu, which was light and creamy with a perfect balance of sweetness and espresso flavor.

Overall, we were thoroughly impressed with our experience at Main Street pizza. The food was outstanding and exceeded our expectations, and the service was exceptional. We would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a delicious meal in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere.

In addition to their amazing deep dish pizza, we noticed that they had a wide range of Italian dishes on their menu, so we are definitely planning on returning to try more of their offerings. If you're in the mood for a fantastic dining experience, we highly recommend giving Main Street pizza a try - you won't be...

I cannot say enough about this place! The food is out of this world! They have every kind of customization you could really want on a pizza. The small pizza? Can easily feed four people. The large pizza? Can easily feed a half an army. I've never tried the sheet pizza but I can only imagine how many people it can feed. Now, this isn't one of those places that gives you huge portions but the food is mediocre. This is easily the best pizzeria I've ever had except for the small town one I grew up on. They also just expanded to have a great restaurant attached to the pizza shop which is also divine. But I am here to gloat about the pizzeria. Where I have to go to next is the wings. One word to describe them? Perfect. 32 wing flavors, then to different styles of cooking them. My fiance and I are on our way to trying every wing flavors and rank them. Our top flavors are the Chipotle BBQ which is cooked on a charcoal grill and then the country sweet is another favorite. But we have only tried a third of the flavors lol. One is over on the charcoal grill and then your regular frying. The charcoal is my absolute favorite because it gives you that fried crunch but also that extra little bit of love from the charcoal. Lastly for dessert, my favorite thing to get is their Strawberry covered friend dough. Oh. My. Lanta. Amazing. It's the best combo of sweet and fruity and fried. Now the only thing is, I wish we could try more than two flavors at a time with the meal deal wings. But they do have some wing flights that I have been wanting to try. But overall? I think you can tell by what I said earlier. Prices are a going rate but it isn't what you pay for quality wise........ It's a lot better. You get a great amount of food for not really that much money. But just as a warning, always get more wings. Best you'll get...

We discovered how good the food and service is at Main Street Pizza during the year-end holidays many years ago, so now it's an annual tradition for us. This year, there were four of us for an early dinner on the Saturday after New Year's. The restaurant was maybe half-full when we arrived at 4:30 pm and we were seated quickly with menus. Don't let the restaurant name fool you. While they do have delicious pizzas, their menu offerings are far more extensive than that. Although some of their prices are a bit higher than what you might find at some other Italian restaurants, the food quality, generous portion sizes, and service may explain some of that additional cost. The atmosphere in their dining room is very pleasant but it can be a bit noisy when it's full. Our group ordered a flight of wings with assorted sauces, rigatoni with a 1-pound meatball, spaghetti with 1-pound meatball, a large Nite Club sub sandwich, lasagna, plus sodas. Our meals were served up around 20 minutes later. The portion sizes were large enough where we could eat and be full but still take half of our meals home. The entrees included a somewhat ordinary chef salad. Everyone's meal was absolutely delicious, portion sizes were a bit overwhelming, and the service throughout dinner was very good. Our total bill for the wings, four meals plus beverages was roughly $108 plus tax. Like I said earlier, although some of the prices here might be higher than at some other restaurants, the food quality, generous portion sizes, and service have never disappointed us. A good time to arrive here for best dinner seating is usually before 5:00 PM (especially on Fri & Sat) when the restaurant starts to fill up. Free parking in the back lot is usually ample unless the restaurant is full. Enjoy, and thanks...