Anna's Restaurant — Restaurant in City of Newburgh

Used to be the best place. Went today for lunch. Specifically asked if the soup was orzo, was told yes. It came, not orzo and also not hot. Ordered a special sandwich with no tomatoes. Said it twice, no tomatoes. Came out with tomatoes. Told the girl who brought it back to the kitchen and within 30 seconds it was back. I opened and saw they just removed tomatoes instead of remaking. When she finally checked on us I handed her back the sandwich and told her they just took off the tomatoes. She then began to argue with me that I didnt tell her no tomatoes. HELLO IM ALLERGIC TO TOMATOES. I even asked the person I was with and confirmed I did say no tomatoes. She kept it in the kitchen until my friend was done eating then brought me back the exact same sandwich with extra pesto on it. I took one bite and immediately my throat got itchy. So I didn't eat lunch...but had to pay for it. This tells me either the kitchen guy was too lazy to remake it or Peter was too cheap to fix their mistake. Also my friend ordered brown gravy with his fries. It was pure flour and water, it wasnt even brown. This place has gone down hill over the past couple of years. Keep trying hoping it got better again but now I know why there were only three tables there...

Holy Souvlaki Greeman!

As a lover of greek cuisine and seafood I must admit that while they don't actually know what Souvlaki means, "on a stick", however, they do make a delicious one.

Ask them to throw fries on your gyro, which they assume is just chicken, and you will be sure to have a delicious greek style Souvlaki.

No disappointments needed, this wonderful gem in the midst of Newburgh deserves your time and money. If you like spanicopita, they also have that too!

As a cool side note, one of th owners is a vinyl junky with a massive record collection, and often DJ's when possible, bringing you soothing sounds of old school hits.

Two thumbs up, I regularly ventured back to this spot for a reasonably priced delicious...

Very nice staff and Customers!!

I say customers because:

Just today, 26 October 2018

I went out for my lunch this resteraunt has been in this area for many decades and I never chose to try it till today. I'm a service member so at the time I was in uniform...as I waited patiently diverse people paid their bill and went on their way.

When my order was ready I was told by, I gather the owner, that it had already been paid for and in fact 2 customers fought over who was going to pay for my lunch! I'm sitting right there and didn't even know that all of this had transpired. Miss Oblivious right? Lol such sweet people. God bless them and I thank them whom ever they are. Thank You! I hope that...