The Reserve — Restaurant in City of Port Jervis

If you find yourself in Port Jervis, NY, and you're in search of an unforgettable drink, look no further than The Reserve. Located in a beautifully restored old bank building, this speakeasy-style bar combines history, ambiance, and world-class drinks into one incredible experience. The space itself feels like a step back in time with its original oak woodwork, soaring ceilings, and plush leather chairs that invite you to sit back and savor your evening.

But what truly sets The Reserve apart is its bartender, Phil Plotkin. A true master of his craft, Phil's cocktails are not just drinks—they're works of art. Each creation is carefully crafted with precision, showcasing his deep knowledge of top-shelf spirits and his passion for mixology. Whether you're in the mood for a classic or something more experimental, Phil's drinks are consistently delicious and second to none. His attention to detail and understanding of flavors make every sip a memorable one.

The Reserve’s spirit selection is equally impressive, with an extensive range of rare and premium bottles that cater to the most discerning whiskey lovers, rum connoisseurs, and anyone in between. Phil is more than happy to share his expertise and guide you through the collection, ensuring you find something that perfectly matches your tastes.

Beyond the drinks, the atmosphere is unparalleled. The dim lighting, vintage décor, and intimate vibe make it the perfect place to unwind, whether you're there for a quiet night out or celebrating something special. Every element of The Reserve, from the carefully curated spirits to Phil’s impeccable service, makes it a standout destination for anyone looking to enjoy a truly exceptional bar experience.

In short, The Reserve is more than just a bar—it's an experience. Phil’s expertise, the top-tier drinks, and the incredible atmosphere make it one of the best places to grab a drink in...

10/10 – Exceptional Experience at The Reserve in Port Jervis!

From start to finish, my visit to The Reserve, in Port Jervis was nothing short of amazing. I can’t recommend it enough – it deserves a solid 10+ out of 10!

The service was top-notch – attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The staff made us feel right at home without being overbearing, and you could tell they genuinely care about giving you the best dining experience.

The food was absolutely delicious. Every dish was crafted with care, and you could taste the high quality of ingredients. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or more adventurous options, The Reserve offers something for everyone.

As for the atmosphere, it perfectly balances modern elegance with historic charm. They’ve done an incredible job preserving the original vibe of the space while adding contemporary touches. It feels like stepping into a piece of history, with a warmth and comfort that makes you want to linger.

If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and make a reservation – you won’t be...

Excellent Atmosphere, Outstanding Service, and Flavorful Food

I visited The Reserve about a week ago after hearing great things through word of mouth—and I’m glad I did! The setting is upscale and welcoming, with a really polished vibe that made a great first impression.

I was greeted right away by Phil, who was professional, kind, and super helpful. He guided me through the menu and made sure I was taken care of from the start. The menu is a bit selective, which I understand, and since I don’t eat meat (except for poultry), I decided to try the truffle fries—and they did not disappoint! They were flavorful, crisp, and truly enjoyable.

I also had the pleasure of meeting CJ, one of the chefs. He was extremely professional, friendly, and carried himself with great mannerism. It’s always a bonus when the kitchen staff is just as engaging as the front-of-house.

Overall, my experience at The Reserve was excellent. Great food, great people, and a great atmosphere—I’ll...